The service, food quality (ingredients and presentation as well as items from the bar are always excellent.

Our group of 5 enjoyed the Cesar and House salads, the tomato soup, 3 different pizzas and cocktails. 900 degrees is perfect when you want a casual atmosphere,and something more than your basic pizza (although they have that as well). The service was fantastic. Our waitress was attentive without being intrusive. She was very knowledgeable about the menu.The salads were... More

Crust is good and thin/crispy. Would just prefer more toppings.

The lil lady and I went for lunch on New Year's. We had heard some good things but expected the price to portion ration to be off a bit. Entry and overall aesthetics were a nice mix of modern industrial chic and elegant downtown Tuscan Village? If that's even possible. Seating was comfortable and the place was dead, we liked... More

I had lunch with a friend of mine and it was okay. The menu is limited and the prices are a bit much for a pizzeria. The food is okay, but it's not something I'd rave about or go out of my way for.

Take it from a NYer, its not NY style, but it is every bit as good. Fresh Mozz, cool bar and live music. Not greasy and thick like NE pizza. A great time is always had in the old mill.

Pizza & other menu items sounded better than they actually tasted, was a little bland.

Avoid the bar -- seats are very uncomfortable. Parking and entrance is challenging, but be persistant!

The pizza is some of the best I've had - thin crust and fresh toppings. Like the bar as well.