Pretty much all the fudge on the island is good, but JoAnn's Fudge is the best flavor and texture. Fantastic English toffee too!

One of the many fudge shops on the island with every flavor imaginable! Great for take home gifts--if they don't find your tummy first!

Having lived in Cheboygan and Mackinaw City for many years I can tell you for a fact that JoAnn's Fudge is one of the best on the island and on the mainland! My suggestion is that you have her send some to your home so you can have your friends and family taste it for themselves. It very hard to... More

We ordered fudge on-line from JoAnn's and it arrived yesterday. So fresh. You can tell it was just made. Highly recommended. We used to live in Michigan and that was the best part about "going up north" was getting fresh made Macinac island fudge. I ordered 5lbs and it arrrived via Priority mail.

Most fudge on Mackinac is grainy, like the sugar wasn't dissolved. JoAnn's is smooth, creamy, and delicious. We actually got a tip from our carriage driver. He said his wife's favorite fudge was JoAnn's (and she was right)!

Without a doubt the best fudge on the Island. I sampled/bought fudge from a few shops, but JoAnn's is just the BEST. Loved their maple fudge - super yummy!

There are many, many places to get fudge on Mackinac Island, but JoAnn's has the best variety and the best service. JoAnn's had a great variety of fudge that was out of this world! The service was great too! We had just purchased fudge elsewhere, but bought quite a bit more here because of the selection and service. Go to... More

Creamiest. Did a side by side taste test with another popular fudge on the island. Both were good. Liked JoAnn's best.

the fudge and price was comparable to others but the staff was friendlier than other places we went in to, and i actually liked how they wrapped the fudge better than the other place