Always delicious! Perfect pizza! Friendly staff. Consistently high quality food. We visit almost every time we're on Cape.
We stopped here for a quick lunch as we could not yet get into our motel room and we needed to kill some time . Typical pizza parlour. You place your order at the counter and you pick it up yourself, no waitress. I thought the owner/cook wasn't too friendly and impatient. I had 3 young boys with me who... More
On a family vacation and stumbled upon this place. At first glance, we wanted to leave since it looks run down. However, the place smelled good and authentic. Wow, great pizza and subs and at a reasonable price too! The large pizza is only 14" so we also got a meatball sub. I am from New York and eat in... More
Looking for that typical Greek Pizza House from yesteryear, than go no further. Toly's is a that place where you used to go as a kid, except it still exists, right down to the Pacman video game in the dining room. Good pizza, hot oven grinders, and greek salads. Self service, reasonable prices. Call ahead for and takeout. Bring the... More
Horrible pizza, worst pizza I have ever eaten! I couldn't believe it. We stopped in late about 9:15 on weekend evening for just a cheese pizza. We took the pizza to go home. I couldn't believe how undercooked, greasy, doughy and tons of cheese this pizza was. Never again!
witnessed the owner smoking by the kitchen (inside the building!!) then handling food, with no gloves or hand washing. I didn't say anything, but threw the food away. If you will smoke in your kitchen in full view of your guests I can only imagine what happens behind the scenes. Horrified. I wouldn't eat there if you paid me
I've live on the Cape for 30yrs and this was the first time I've eaten at Toly's. I think there's nothing worse then walking into any establishment and seeing the employees looking vry unhappy..... It sets the tone! I ordered a calzone and was vry disappointed the it only came in one size which was just an 8 inch.... I... More
i recently visited this sub shop and ordered an italian sub thank god i checked the sandwich before eating it i found a long piece of hair and the inside of the bread had mold! i recommned all tourists and curious eaters to keep away from this place
Working in this area I try to get to Toly's a few times a month for lunch. Love their greek salads and BLT subs! Willy Billy does a nice job.
Stopped in after a day of whale watching. The pizza had an excellent crust and was loaded with cheese. A great pie!
If you own or manage Toly's House of Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing