The service was good. Food average. Little trouble with temperature...vegetable was completely cold. Potato, meat and crab average.Pricey considering the average food.
This restaurant looks nice and feels quite homey with pick a tablecloth and place settings and lots of wood in the interior. The menu has pretty standard items like sandwiches, burger, some steaks and crab cakes. I ordered chicken Parmesan, only to be told they didn't serve that anymore. The waiter dropped a glass of water on one of my... More
We have dined for lunch a number of times at Matthew's 1600 when in the Catonsville area. Each time we have enjoyed the lunch time specials that include a delicious quiche dish or an over stuffed sandwich (plus other choices from soups to main dinners). Today the special sandwich was roasted beef, zesty dressing, onion ring and bacon that came... More
I met some folks on a Thursday night for dinner. We were in the dining room around the bar in the middle. Dinner conversation was done by screaming at each other across the table. It was so loud it was not pleasant. Food was ok. A bit over priced. Don't go out of your way. But if you want a... More
While I have driven by this place at least a 100 times, Saturday night was the first time I ate there. We were meeting friends for dinner at 6 and at 5 I thought I should make reservations. There are two choices the dining room or the bar. I asked for the dining room and they took about five minutes... More
On May 11, 2013 my husband and I visited the Resturant at about 5:30p and asked the host if she could fit us in without a reservation. She said sure follow me, we were seated and surprised that it wasn't that busy. After waiting 10mins without anyone taking our drink order, my husband asked me why is it taking so... More
I've eaten in the restaurant dining room side of Matthew's 1600 several times, and it's a nice place for dinner.* The food was good, and the room was pretty, but the service was just average. I'd eat there again, but I wouldn't rush back. But more recently, I've eaten in Matthew's bar with friends a number of times. The bar... More
I reside close to this restaurant, frequent often, with mixed reviews. The bar staff is great and pour Strong Drinks!!! The appetizers are good; main entrees are extremely inconsistent and can be great one day and mediocre' the next. Supposedly, the chief is top notch--however; entrees have had to be returned on numerous reason(s), such as, undercooked....overcooked....cold.... Service is Great!!!
I have been going to Matthews 1600 since its opening. Whether for a special event, or dinner out with family, we have never been disappointed. The quiet fine dining room with fireplace is a great spot for date nite, and the bar scene with booths is a great spot for a quick bite with the hubs. Their Surf and Turf... More
I enjoy the ambience of the dining room especially the booths by the windows. The food is very good. My favorite is the chicken crepes which are to die for. What is so frustrating is the inexplicably slow service to the point of being ignored. I'm gay and go there with my partner and wonder if they just don't want... More
If you own or manage Matthew's 1600, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing