The dinner at McSeagulls might well have been the best dinner we had in Maine - and all the others were above average! What a taste treat. And we had a window seat so could look out over the harbor. Prices were reasonable - perhaps slightly more than average but, after all, this was our one big trip of the... more

McSeagulls is our favorite casual dining spot in the area. Fresh seafood, reasonable prices, friendly and efficient service and views of the harbor. I always eat lobster (it's Maine after all) but the menu is large and varied. My spouse has tried other seafood dishes as well beef and they have all been excellent. more

We ate dinner here on a Friday night in August. Our waiter was very attentive and the food was pretty good for a reasonable price. We sat on the outside deck and had a great view of the harbor. I would eat here again. more

You cannot go wrong in selecting Mcseagulls for a really solid waterfront bar/restaurant. While I only ate lunch there I would return without reservation. A menu to suit every taste and pocketbook. Ample portions, fresh ingredients, and great margaritas. My wife's ahi tuna salad was steal at 12.95 with a huge portion of sushi grade tuna seared to perfection. My... more

First trip to Boothbay Harbor, our first restaurant stop McSeagulls. I can't think of a better welcome to a wonderful city. more

Ate here one night and were pleased. The weather was wonderful so we sat on the deck. The food was good and the key lime pie could compete with Key West. We were happy to have servings that were a proper size and not have to throw any away. We were eating earlier then normal and there many children at... more

For a pub, this place is full of surprises. The menu has all of the modern options, liked seared ahi tuna, plus traditional fair, such as fried clams. Everything we have had there is delicious. There is a beautiful upstairs room that we actually used for a cocktail party this month, and were so pleased with the variety of appetizers... more

we were not going to eat here b/c it looked like a typical tourist trap, but we decided to give it a go after looking at their extensive and interesting menu. We shared the tuna burger and lobster burgers and they were both really good. the waitress was cheerful and efficient, and we had a nice table over looking beautiful... more

It looks like a tourist trap with all the beer umbrellas on the deck overlooking the harbor. The food is fresh, of high quality, innovative and very reasonably priced for what you get. We ate there twice in a three day stay. more