Arrived around 6:00pm so the wait was short. The staff and service was excellent. Food was very good but I thought a bit over priced.
We made a last minute Open Table reservation for 4 at Sullivan's. We were seated on time. The food for all of us was fabulous. Bone-in NY Strip for me and it was cooked to perfection. The choices for sides had all the usual suspects with one very notable exception: brussel sprouts. These were chopped, sautéed with onion & bacon... More
My wife had the chicken wrap and I had my usual filet. Both were excellent, both in presentation anD in taste. The server.was always there, if needed, but didn't hover around. The food and atmosphere were more upscale than I was expecting as we were from out of town and did expect that type of restaurant in a shopping mall.... More
My extended family, all 16 of us, come to Sullivan's every December for a pre-Christmas family dinner. We have been doing this every year since the restaurant opened (17 years I think). This year we were seated in the patio section. This was very nice - or I should say, much better than cramming us into the library like they... More
Steak is not prime but is quite good. Prix fixe menu is a good value with app,soup or salad, and 6oz filet or salmon
The braised beef ravioli appetizer was super good and I LOVED, LOVED, LOVED the Kale salad. Perfect dinner, wine and dessert.
Sullivan's has an amazing way of making the date night a perfect occasion. It also makes any other dining event there special. Been to this restaurant more than 20 times and never experienced a single lapse in service, quality or ambiance. Please note: there is a price to pay as Sullivan's is likely the most expensive restaurant in Indianapolis, but... More
We celebrated my husband's birthday at Sullivan's again this year and it did not disappoint. We ordered off the pre-set menu for $39.00 and the choices were great. They even accommodated my request for a soup and salad instead of an appetizer. The portions were perfect and I left feeling full and not stuffed. It was a great meal and... More
The food was very good (ceasar salad, filet, green beans, mashed potatoes), but I was disappointed with the banana bread pudding for dessert. The bananas were very firm, almost hard. Maybe they had been frozen? My steak was cooked as I requested, but others in my group were not.
We visited Sullivan's last night to celebrate our anniversary. The place was really hopping because of the "Northern Nights" promotion (fixed price menu of options-smaller portions). This is absolutely the best way to go if you want a lovely dinner out at a high quality establishment! I had a Caesar salad, 6 oz filet & key lime pie for $30.... More
If you own or manage Sullivan's Steakhouse, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing