My family and I have been here 3 times in the last two years. Overall they always offer generous portions and the selections are very fresh. Among the favorites for us are crab cakes (my favorite), grilled shrimp, harvest cobb salad, waldorf salad side, carrot and raisin salad side, pumpkin muffin. I can see the reviews are somewhat polarized, either... more

I was at SSI for 5 days this past week (5/21-5/26). Ate at 4th of May at least 5 times (breakfast and lunch somedays). Everything we had was wonderful. Squash casserole, tomato pie, Waldorf Salad, etc. Breakfast - omelets, sausage biscuits, French Toast, etc. On the last night we even got chicken salad plate to go and my husband and... more

Indifferent waitress with incorrect information about the food, dry overcooked chicken, boiled to death green beans, dried out mac and cheese, basically inedible food. You'd be better off at a drive thru. more

Tuna & Vegie Sandwich! more

Do the breakfast thing, then on another day do lunch. Do not try to do both on the same day. Outstanding family-style place. Don't expect dainty portions. They don't exist here. And there is nothing that isn't really, really good. more

I had heard some nice things about the restaurant. We went on Dec. 31 for lunch. There were four of us. 2 finally received food but the other 2 never did. When approached about it, the server rolled her eyes. The two who had received their food finally finshed the meal. The other two (my husband and I) still received... more

From reviews here and elsewhere I had expectations of a great place to grab lunch. Unfortunately, our visit to 4th of May Deli was the lowlight of our trip to SSI. After being seated at the rear of the restaurant, my niece noticed a roach crawling over the utensil bin, which is below the area the cooks pass the dishes... more

If I lived on the island (again), I could easily eat a meal a day at this place. During our two-and-a-half months on Saint Simons, we tried most of the menu and took all our guests there at least once. I was never disappointed and often wowed. I came home with a copy of their cookbook, which is a great... more

Got to SSI Friday night about 7:30 and decided to go to 4th of May as it was one of our must eat ats. Not crowded at all. Server Keisha was very friendly, although she did get a couple of things mixed up. Got the 2 item combo. Both of us got a crab cake, I added fried oysters and... more