Definitely the best NY style pizza by the slice in Tampa. Sauce is slightly tangy, great cheese and crispy crust and the dough is made with NY water!!

Eddie & Sam's New York Pizza boasts using water shipped in from New York to make their dough. Although the pizza was very good, I find that hard to swallow. How can you run a business in downtown Tampa, have water shipped in from the northeast and then charge $2.50 for a slice of pizza? Besides the pizza, we ordered... More

It is hard for me to remember and compare to Lombardi's in NYC or De Lorenzo's (Trenton, NJ), but this is good stuff!! We shared (and had plenty to take home) the 20" pie and they also make one that is 28 inches!!. It is a Pizza should be: The crust is thin, crusty and is firm enough to fold... More

If you like NY style pizza, do not miss this downtown landmark. They have there water delivered from New York twice a week. This is the best pizza in all of Tampa Bay. Period. Not even a close second. If anyone tells you they had better NY style pizza at a different place in Tampa; they are uninformed or flat... More

Eddie & Sam's is amazing! It's the only place I know outside of NYC with this kind delicious pizza. You can't go wrong with anything here from the pizza to the gelato. I love the chicken parmesan and pepperoni pizza. The chicken roll is also great.

Amazing pizza and good price. Do not leave Tampa, Florida without stopping at this place. It is real New York Style Pizza. There meaty calzone is tasty too. Family friendly, staff is great, and the food is amazing.

There's someone who lives in my building and orders from this place every week (I always see a pizza box in the trash room) and I figured I'd better try it since its such a staple in their life. We grabbed a slice one night and it was absolutely delicious. The place is kind of a hole (things weren't re-stocked,... More

Go early for lunch there is always a line...But it moves fast. Pizza is superb! Nice lunch spot. Once you go there, you will return!

I love pizza, so I wanted to try a few places in Tampa. Since this was rated very high, I figured it was a good bet. And I was not disappointed... in fact, it was better than I expected! The pizza tasted so good, I could have eaten an entire one in one sitting! We sat outside because the weather... More