City Pizza was good value. The pizza was tasty and the pasta dishes were generous. Take away and pick up options are available.
I have to say, this was one of the worst meals I ever ate. Actually I didn't eat it, I threw most of it out. We were looking for a quick meal so we tried City Pizza. I had the chicken marsala and my husband had the veal parmesan. They were both equally bad. It reminded us of cafeteria food... More
Well, I still love their pizza, I miss the old decor. Some would call it outdated, I called it quaint. I miss the fish tank with their multicoloured fish. If you look after your fish this well, you will look after me too.The Pizza is still wonderful.
Great staff, great pizza. Kids had burger and pasta, they eat every drop. Yum. Our server was very funny too. Would go back no problem.
We were vacationing on Siesta Key and ordered carry-out. The white pizza was delicious and the calzones were excellent. If I was ordering again, especailly at lunch, I'd definitely split the calzone. They are huge!!! The owners are very friendly.
Been looking for a good new pizza place locally, and came across this the other day while coming back from Turtle Beach. Love the craft beer selection--seriously, if you like crafts, this is the only place on the island that will wow you...you have to try the creme brûlée vanilla stout--blew my mind. Only thing that would have made the... More
The place was empty at dinner time, which should have warned me, but I was absolutely starving. Once inside it didn't "smell Italian": warning bell number 2. Still, I ordered their meat lovers and it was disappointing. Cheese was an unusual consistency and lacked the tomato flavor one expects. The meat itself was stingy and not flavorful. And, for all... More
I have been eating at City Pizza when they first opened with only 3-4 tables. They move several doors down and have been going there weekly since then. I absolutely LOVE the Stromboli and lasagna. Being from New York I've had years of taste testing pizza for over 40 yrs. The owners are great friendly and happy atmosphere. Service has... More
Crispy crust on a pizza is a must and we finally found it at City Pizza. No more limp pies. The salad was really fresh and now we're on a mission to find their brand of Sangria. A small pizza fed both of us easily with leftovers. Impressive fish tank too! Will be back with friends.
Since it is September, seating was no problemo. It is not much on atmosphere but it was convenient. I ordered the spaghetti w/ meat sauce with a side salad and a drink. Came to $20 for lunch which is a bit high. Buuuut they bring a monstrous amount of food. I have a BIG appetite and had to get a... More
If you own or manage City Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing