We had the opportunity to dine here twice during our recent visit to Sarasota. Great food, great service and reasonable prices. Portions are large and we boxed leftovers both times. The prime rib was fantastic and the pies were all delicious. All employees were very pleasant. If you are late diners plan on dining early as they close at 8pm.... more

You can tell that they pay attention to making sure the customer has good food for a good value. Yoder's had good fresh food for lunch and a nice sized pie menu. You won't go away hungry as they make sure you have plenty of quality food. more

Good stuff - everything is good more

Great restaraunt with great staff, great food, great prices and even greater portions. Dont miss it!!! more

Wow! if you want home-cooking, fast and friendly service, large portions and freshly baked pies this is the place to visit. By far the best restaurant we visited on our vacation to Florida. Prices are very reasonable, and most everyone left with a take-out container. They advise you order your pie early on during your meal, for good reason -... more

Great Home Cooking, Pies to die for more

My parents moved to Longboat Key at couple of years ago and have been systematically going through the local restaurants. By far, our favorite Amish/home cooking place is Yoder's. The service is always excellent, they give entirely too much food and it is always excellent. Like the best your mother can make with the added bonus of dozens of pie... more

Bland food, there pies are good. more

Yoder's has the best pies in town, bar none. And some great home cooking. more