It shouldn't take two hours to be waited on! Then to be rude and tell us to leave because we were an embarrassment to you????? Isn't veryone supposed to receive their meal at the same time. If a customer complains, shouldn't the management do whatever they can to make it right. You lost fifteen customers tonight! Shame on you. More

Found out about Goodfellas from friends. What a little gem this place is! Not very big inside, but cute, quaint atmosphere. They make their own wine, which is quite good. And a darn good pizza! One of ther better pizzas I've had in Sarasota. I don't understand why we don't have more good pizza places here? A good value here... More

Went to this resturant on Tripadvisor's recommendation and was not disappointed with my pizza, In fact, I went back a second evening. Great thin based pizza baked in an Italian oven fired with oak timber. More

It is truly rare in this day and age to discover a real gem in a sea of rough diamonds. However, Goodfellas Cafe & Winery offers two ingredients not found in local eateries-especially those featuring Italian Cuisine-quality ingredients properly blended. My wife and I actually went to this establishment with high expectations having been referred by a local chef/owner of... More

Word of mouth, both good and bad, travels fast in this town. We recently heard some favorable comments about this place and were all excited to try them for pizza and wine before a movie. We heard they had a new 800 degree wood burning pizza oven which turns out wonderful pizza, so we were expecting to experience something really... More

Positives: very friendly owner and staff,warm atmosphere, cool oil bar where you can try several varieties, Prices were great, pizza was very good for that style crust which is very thin but not my fav style. Negatives: pasta dish was served cold.wondering if frozen,sauce bland, wine they bottle or make from CA grapes tasted like wine we've tried made in... More

First, this place is pizza heaven. The other Italian food is very good too. The pizza has very thin crust, but the edges can get charred. Still tastes good. The service is rather informal, but good and very friendly. Frank the owner is a nice guy and friendly. He remembers most of his customers. The place looks like a dive,... More

Ate here with the kids. Wasn't that expensive. My wife did not like her food...some type of spaghetti (can't really remember). I tasted it and it was a little peculiar so could see why she was not crazy about it. The rest of us had dishes with meatballs. The meatballs were pretty good...I've had better and have had worse. Don't... More

We had a great pizza and a bottle of their wine for $20. Got there early so no wait. You have to have their bread and dipping oil. Excellent wait person.We'll be back More