We visited Mc’t to try the all-you-can eat shrimp selections that I had read about on a previous forum. I started with the original shrimp done with Old Bay Seasoning. They were pretty good. Decided to try the Cajun version. Oh my gosh talk about good. I ended up eating 2 1/2 more plates. They were yummy. The juices that... more

We ate here several times on previous visits and enjoyed it, so we had to go back again this year! It was abysmal.....dirty tables, run down fixtures and shabby decor. Then there was the food....fried, greasy and unappealing. Never again! more

I have been visiting Sanibel since I could barely walk, and McT's has been included in every trip. I understand they have changed management and ownership a time or two, but the basic restaurant hasn't changed much. I will admit that service and quality lacks consistency, but I have noticed that the decrease in quality and service is proportional to... more

May 30, 2008-The atmosphere may be ho-hum, but the food was great. We had excellent soft shell crab and Dover sole, which were mouth-watering. If you want seafood, this place will deliver. Drinks were also well made. more

I think the draw of this restaurant is the all you can eat shrimp & crab legs, most people around us were eating either one of those offerings. My husband & I has the shrimp cocktail which was good & the buffalo shrimp which was heavily coated and a costume for really small shrimp. Our entrees were ok, grouper encrusted... more

We went to McT's based on an enthusiastic recommendation from a fellow traveler. We had good service and good food -- an all-around enjoyable experience, though the restaurant is really dark inside. It was only when we got back to our room and referenced the reviews here on TripAdvisor did we learn that McT's has been slipping. We had a... more

Went there lastnight. 4/23/2008. Was very skeptical after reading the below reviews. Thought we would give happy hour a try and if it was good would try dinner. Happy hour we had a couple of beers and some crab legs. Very good. Our server Jeff was new but very attentive. I had the stuffed shrimp and my beautiful wife had... more

Five of us made our annual visit to McT's expecting the same good service and good food as in prior years. Three of us order the same Mahi-Mahi. Two tasted OK but my wife's was rotten tasting. All the other food was average at best. What a disappointment! The waiter would do nothing to make it right and when asked... more

March 2008 - I wouldn't waste my time here, if you're looking for a nice, peaceful meal. Wait staff and host/manager were rude, obviously burnt out on waiting on tourist. Host/manager walked right past us three times, even tho we were the only people waiting to be seated. Went later in the evening, since the place was mobbed during rush... more