This is my families first visit to Sanibel, and our conclusion is that the restaurants here are pretty much a joke! They are sooo overpriced, it is insulting! Island Pizza has good pizza at great prices. We had delivery twice, after shelling all day, the kids are tired and don't want to leave the room. On my second order, the... more

The pizza here is fast, fresh and delicious. It is New York style with a special roll up crust that was really good. The dining area is very "generic pizza place" inside but no one cares because the food is so good. more

We enjoyed the Island Pizza restaurant so much that we went back a second time! I must confess that I am not much of a pizza eater, but my dh and I really enjoyed the pizza at the Island Pizza. We were impressed that we could customize our pizza and add additional toppings to it w/out additional charge. That's unheard... more

We arrived just prior to closing on a Wednesday night and were greeted right away by the bar tender at the front door and he polietly welcomed us and set the tone for a great experience. Having worked in the food industry for 15 years and seeing the good with the bad, this place has gotten it figured out. Family... more

My waitress was really sweet, my food was delicious, service is great, and I really enjoyed the atmosphere. I would recommend this place to anyone who likes great waitresses and an island atmosphere. more

Sure it's busy Saturday nights, but they were doing me a favor taking my order over the phone. The Pizza was undercooked, and was lacking in SAUCE, the heart and soul of good pizza! The 'White pizza' is glorified garlic bread, and deceptive in that it is refered to as 'Pizza' i.e. no sauce. (see above comment). will not darken... more

If we were at home, this wouldn't be our favorite pizza restaurant, but on Sanibel, there's not much choice. They do put lots of toppings on, especially on the Islander special. The crust is sort of gross, though-- soggy and limp. We have eaten there 3 times, twice for takeout and once in the restaurant. A large and a medium... more

Plain and simple: I ordered my food and they did not deliver it. I called after a hour, the employee said, "it will be there any minute," then he hung up on me. I tried to call back and my calls went to a voice mailbox. Luckily, my wife ordered me to stop waiting (after 2 hours and 5 minutes... more

The pizza with the curly crust is so chewy and tasty. The rosemary chicken dish is super! more