Always a delicious treat, delicious creations and friendly staff! Always busy, but you usually get served promptly, and they provide free samples to ensure you enjoy your selection!

I had the Mixed Berry, Dirty Sand Dollar and Sanibel Krunch. They were awesome. I will go back to again before my trip is over. If you are in Sanibel, this is a "must do". All seating is outside. If you're not sure about a particular flavor, ask for a sample.

Had the same dark chocolate ice cream two days in a row and wish our trip hadn't ended the next morning or would have gone back again. They give generous portions and the staff is friendly.

Close to the lighthouse. Nice place for an ice cream after dinner. Don't get the low fat ones, because they fall apart and you lose 1/2 of it if you have a cone.

It was about two miles from our hotel, so this was a perfect destination for a short bike ride. Ice cream was very good, although I am not sure about the definition of 'original Italian', it came from PA, maybe some Italians founded a company there...And portions were huge, a 2-scoops could easily satisfy 2+ people

Ice cream is above average. I got the sanibel crunch. Nice flavor, mouthfeel not ideal ( a little Ivey feeling). Price seemed pretty average. It came to 8 something for two small dishes. Serving sizes are big.

We were driving on the end of the island by the lighthouse and saw Pinocchio's. The day before, we met a couple of folks while walking the Ding Darling trail, and they mentioned how good this place was. So we followed up on his suggestion. I got the Sanibel Krunch and watermelon ice cream on a waffle cone. I think... More

What a delicious variety of Italian Ice Creams. They even had several sugar free, fat free varieties. I had the Mocha Chocolate sugar free and it was wonderful. My family raved about the Wedding Cake with Almond and the Sanibel Crunch. Portions were huge... even the small was an ample size. Wish we would have found this place earlier in... More

Lines too long but we went late at nite to avoid crowds but even some nights lines would too long to wait. good ice cream tho