Got a pie. I'm a New Yorker. As good as anywhere, actually better! Got the regular thin crust cheese.
We've tried pizzas from other places, always go back to Toby's for the best & love the garlic knots! Hot sandwiches are good too!
Open every day, always busy. Not fancy. Order and pick up at the counter. Known for their great pizza, but also a very good antipasto, and glasses or pitchers of beer. Lots of take-out customers stopping by also. But they are well-organized and staffed with enough people to get the orders out fairly quickly. Small and large thin crust pizzas,... More
I went to Toby's for the first time today. Ordered their large thin crust. The Pizza was excellent with good crust. The Pizza was so large it took up most of the table. They have all the pizza fixings at every table. The place is very clean and new looking. Well staffed and very busy for a weekday lunch time.... More
I've been to this place dozens of dozens of times and never thought to review it. I guess it's because it just feels so comfortable. This place gets it done. It always draws a crowd and the service is quick and efficient - and has been for years. The pizza is the best that I've found in town. They're generous... More
I love the pizza here and meet friends here sometimes for lunch. So much better than pizza chain pizza! I wish they had table service; but I realize they've been a local favorite for a long time and probably know what works best for them.
I started going to Little Italy when it first opened in 1972. I used ride my bicycle up there with other friends, Although I live out of state, I do stop by once or twice per year. Their Pizza continues to be the one of the best I have ever had! Sub sandwiches and calzones, all still as good as... More
Looking for some takeout on a recent trip to St. Pete. This was close so we tried it. Absolutely delicious! Ordered the white pizza and garlic knots. I'd have both shipped to me in Connecticut if I could! Prices very reasonable.
Great authentic Italian food, run by Italians! Always delicious and first quality. Cute game room in the back. Great place for all ages; also excellent spot to take the grandchildren for pizza (and more!), sit in the back game-room and bring some quarters for the amusement machines. Lots of fun for all, and much better than going to Chucky Cheese... More
I've been fortunate to be a customer for twenty plus years and have been satisfied with my experience in all of them. A+ service.
If you own or manage Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing