Raco, the owner is rude and arogant. The cashier / order taker is rude and does not know the menu. The food is not consistant. It's more like pot luck or a box of chocolates. The owner thinks the place is clean, lol , what a joke! I will not return.

Pizza by the slice or the whole pizza pie either way you get a huge slice a piece New York style that falls in the best pizza ever. Crust cooked perfectly Garlic knots are a must when coming here

No ones hand tossed NY can beat Toby's. Make sure, You ask for fresh mushrooms unless you like the slimy ones out of the can. NY attitude with every pie, know the drill (typical order/pay - get a # - pick up your pie when your # is called) and you'll get along fine.

yummy quick and reasonable prices. very close to NY pizza. only downer is limited seating. it is the locals pizza joint, just go n Friday night n u will see

Small place but some of the best italian American food in town. Simple but great menu for lunch or dinner without breaking the bank. Been around and been too for many years and will keep comming back. A true local fav

The gang of 8 went to Toby's on 49th street St Petersburg last night. It is the second time around for some of the gang. It was as good as the first time. I enjoy Toby's for food and the atmosphere. People interact with one another. The food is exceptional. Thin crust, oven baked pizza done well. The subs are... More

great pizza, philly cheesesteak sandwichs, garlic knots, EVERYTHING. glad they expanded the seating great place to grab a slice or a whole pie... just know that the small pizza is the size of most place' large garlic knots are a favorite you order at the counter and go find a table and wait for your number to be called you... More

Really good NY style pizza, thin crust, crunchy edges. Traditional toppings and normal pizza parlor offerings. If you're on the north side and need your pizza fix this is your place. Stick with Spartan Pizza if you're in the south. Just as good without the drive.

I have been going there since my parents took me there as a kid and its like it never changed. I REALLY love the cheesteaks and the garlic knots are to die for.