High end seafood, good menu selection of fresh seafood, service was excellent, good drinks, wonderful ambiance
Does this restaurant serve lobster roll?
Does this restaurant serve crab cake?
Does this restaurant serve lobster?
Does this restaurant serve oysters?
Does this restaurant serve ribs?
Does this restaurant serve crab?
Does this restaurant serve shrimp?
Is this restaurant good for local cuisine?
Is this restaurant good for business?
Does this restaurant serve paella?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
We had looked forward to trying this restaurant and had not made a reservation so we had to take pot luck with seating. The place was very crowded and it was only 5:00 in the afternoon. We had a pleasant waiter who answered our questions but kept trying to take our order after we told him we wanted to relax... More
Great meal really enjoyed the calamari fries appetizer. Always enjoy the food. Plan on returning soon and coming back many times. Like the early birds because they give you great food at great prices.
I have been to this restaurant several times in the past, but my wife had never been. We had The Chilean Sea Bass and the Hog Fish. Both dishes well prepared and tasted great. The service from our server, Pete, was superb. The wine list is good and reasonably priced.
6pm Monday visit, very comfortable atmosphere. very nice menu to choose from. we had shrimp small plate, mash potatoes and the mix fish. All was wonderful. Salmon, Hog fish and swordfish were all very tasty with different sauces and preparations. good wine list at reasonable pricing. Looks like early bird you need to be seated before 5:30pm. better pricing on... More
We love this restaurant. Located in a small strip mall you must suspend judgement until you taste this food! The service is excellent (especially Eric). The fish is lovingly prepared and perfect....textures and tastes. Don't miss the Sea Bass! The Lobster Bisque is a great starter but leave room for a desert bite. We especially love Mystic Fish's version of... More
It's been a staple in Palm Harbor for a few years now. service is always good. They've changed the menu so more "small plates" and seems like less full entrees. Seafood always good, but switched it up and had their NY Strip which was actually pretty chewy. Didn't have time to send back so made due....
My family of 11 visited Mystic Fish during a recent trip to Florida. We made reservations, and our group was seated almost immediately upon arrival. The food was excellent. Members of our group had various seafood, steak, chicken, salads, and other dishes. Everyone was pleased. If we are ever back in this area, we will definitely visit again.
My wife and I arrived a few minutes before our reservation and were seated immediately (on a Saturday night). The place was packed but our server, April, was very attentive and took our drink order right away. We decided to order a number of small plates to taste multiple dishes. I started with mussels which were tasty but very tiny.... More
This is our special occasion place, this year it was valentines day. The tables can be booked on Open Table so I was able to get my table plenty early. The appetizers, entre items and deserts are all exquisitely prepared by the chef and absolutely delicious. The staff is very accommodating and service is excellent. Make your reservations ahead of... More
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing