We always schedule a special dinner here each time that we visit Miami Beach. The service is outstanding, the food is top notch and experience is to die for. It is a true Italian experience without being in Italy.

Travelers' Choice® 2012 Winner
Restaurants
We always schedule a special dinner here each time that we visit Miami Beach. The service is outstanding, the food is top notch and experience is to die for. It is a true Italian experience without being in Italy.
Looooved this place from the moment we areived. My boyfriend and i are from Cleveland and love the vibe and food found in the quaint Italian restaurants in Cleveland's Little Italy - this place blew them out of the water. The pwner greeted us with a smile and some joking around, and our server continued the friendly, fun service and...
More
Recommended by a local artist ( Miami art centre George Goodridge - thank you!) So if it's good for the locals you know it is good. We did book, and glad we did, as it does get busy. The waiters are attentive and will guide you through the special boards. I had the tiger shrimp though did get the waiter...
More
Traveling with a group of friends to Miami. Saw my friend Shane's positive recommendation on Trip Advisor so we made a reservation for five. Small, intimate place which was refreshing. Glad we had called for reservations.
What fun! Our waiter was so nice, an original, he had worked at the restaurant for 25 years. Food was great Italian, with some...
More
Busy and friendly ambience with lots of Italian standards on the menu. We both had risotto which was perfectly executed. Quite pricey but this is South Beach.
Bread was not tasty like in Italy and tuna's carpaccio was not fresh either. Although main corse - lamb was pefrect, waiters are friendly and quick. I beleive something wrong with restarant's rating because it does not match real customer experience.
We went just before closing and the food and service were excellent. One of the best Italian meals ever. The fresh tuna pasta was stunning.
Went here for dinner last night..lovely intimate setting...service very attentive...food was fabulous really had a wonderful evening...yes it is high priced but isn't everything overpriced in south beach
This is the best italian restaurant in Miami. The service and food area fantastic, prices are fair for what you get.
we went for dinner there mid week. Place was busy, staff were professional (a change from Miami Beach generally, where looks count more than ability).
Food was a non event, nothing wrong with it but given the cost of the main courses it should deliver more, the rating should be 3 1\2 as it was above average but below very...
More
If you own or manage Osteria del Teatro, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing