My family and I ate at the Island Fish Company during our recent trip to Marathon. The atmosphere was great! The food was very good. They have a lot of different things to choose from on their menu. My husband ordered the filet mignon and said it was good. I ordered the Shrimp Diane and enjoyed it very much. It... more

tourist trap more

This restaurant was fantastic! The location was great, we overlooked the gulf, you could tie your boat up to the dock and have a great meal. Our waitress was very attentive and gave excellent service. My husband and I had yummy conch fritters, I had delicious fresh swordfish, and my husband had great stuffed shrimp. The atmosphere was open and... more

Island Fish Company was our best dining experience while on Marathon: Excellent food, million dollar sunset view, very good service, excellent food, very good drinks, very friendly staff especially in the Tiki Bar, great atmosphere, very crowded for dinner if you go at peak time, limited parking. I would rank Island Fish Company in my top tier of great restaurants.... more

Four of us went for a late lunch. We were seated on the "deck" under a nice umbrella, thankfully. The service was quite good and so was the food. The meal was quite pleasant with a limited but nice view right on the water. Our four person poll said we'd go back, with a doubt. more

We ate at the Island Fish Company thinking "this is going to be great". Not great, eh ok more like it. The wait was ok,, we were told 45 minutes but only waited 15. The server was good and friendly and good with kids. The food was ok. But the atmosphere is great, so I would go back again. It... more

I had been here 1x prior with some friends march/09 , and when I was down agian at he begining of april/09 with my husband I wanted him to taste the really good key lime mustard suace they use as well as great seafood . we enjoyed the food but the waiter was very obnoxious along with some loud mouthed... more

This place is great. We come here every time we are in the Keys. We love the low key atmosphere and the food is awesome! Drinks are great. Beautiful sunsets. more

My husband and i were really looking forward to trying more fresh fish and different varieties as we are in The Keys. We started with a garden salad and home made thousand island dressing and zesty italian- My husband does not like vinegarettes but loved this one. He also had the dozen oysters- loved them!!! We then moved on to... more