This was our very first time eating at Island Fish Company, We called around a few places to see who was serving breakfast before setting off on the road from our hotel, we came across this restaurant as it was fairly close to were we were staying at, It "seemed" like a nice laid back atmosphere, the tiki appeal was... More

We stumbled on this place while driving to Key West. What a great atmosphere! Good service and great food! This place gives you the feeling of being on a tropical island! We ordered the Key West Shrimp taco's and they were amazing! Rich filling and not just one shrimp but multiple! On our way back to Miami we will come... More

8 of us that ate here today.....staff seemed nice our waitress Ashley was awesome. Appetizer conch fritters were great. Food came out pretty quick, kids had nachos and chicken fingers which were ok, I got cheesesteak sandwich that was good, husband got fish tacos he says were excellent! We had a small problem with about 4 flies who just kept... More

This place was right across from our hotel, so it was very convenient. Yummy food. I got the macho chicken nachos, which were huge! I also ordered the key lime colada, which was kind of a small drink but still delicious. My husband got a burger, which he was happy with. My friend ordered the coconut shrimp, which were flaky... More

Stop here many times while traveling. Wait staff always friendly and very helpful. Food is very over price. Had ordered pasta with seafood and like all taking out freezer. No fresh taste.

The restaurant offers a good variety of menu items. We have had lunch there several times and the food is tasty and the service we have had has been good. I often get the side of broccoli and cauliflower which is served plain. It would be much more appealing if they had a seasoning on it and the veggies weren't... More

We ate here last week and had one of the best meals we've ever had. It's a casual restaurant with seats right on the water at a small marina. We ate and watched the sun go down and had the best Mahi-Mahi and calamari we've ever had. Great service and reasonable prices made for a memorable meal.

We have been at this restaurant several times, never thought it was great, but we decided to give it another try, I ordered the Hog Fish, pan sauted , dusted lightly in flour with butter, garlic , lemon, that fished came out pale like steam fish, no flavor to it, I think for $24.95, they could get pan seared and... More

This is not a fine dining atmosphere by any means with tables interspersed with park bench type seating. The drinks come in plastic cups. But it's nice to be by the water.There is a very large menu of items available that is probably hit-or-miss depending on what you choose. We had the calamari and peel-and-eat shrimp, which were both good... More