While there is nothing fancy about the place, the food and even the quietly efficient service were outstanding. Everyone in our family loved the food. It was fresh and well prepared. If you are impressed with restaurants that make their average food look fabulous, this is not the place for you. The food here almost looks like a meal you... More

As a working fish market near the docks, Fish Tales always has a wide array of fresh fish, both for their market as well as their restaurant. Additionally, they are the absolute best source of prime & choice meats in the area. The owners actively work the business and extremely friendly & helpful. They have 10 tables for lunch, but... More

Love the food, and the people who work there! We eat here often, great steaks and seafood. Wait staff is right on top of everything.

I was looking for fresh seafood to cook at home. I took a chance with Fish Tales and was pleasantly surprised. Great selection of seafood that looked like it was right off the boat. Owner was very friendly and helpful. I didn't eat at the small restaurant but it looked like a great place for lunch or sandwich. There was... More

Enjoyed our lunch here. It is a very small place. Nothing fancy. When we came in with our large family, they bent over backwards to seat us. Got the idea this is a locals hangout. All enjoyed our lunch. Our 12 yr.old daughter said their lobster bisque was probably the best she's ever had!

Bought fresh shrimp and stone crab claws here. Cooked them at home in beer and old bay seasoning. Yumm

We thoroughly enjoyed eating the fish at fish tales and we plan to return on our next visit to the keys. It is a fish market, not fine dining. This is where you go for good reasonably priced fish while in the middle keys.

And very fresh fish. The woman that runs the market was extremely helpful in spite of my inability to make any decisions. She made sure that we got the freshest Hogfish that they had and it was great thanks to her tips on how to cook it . This will be the only place I buy fish from in the... More

This is a locals favorite, just look at the small bar area which is full with loacls catching a quick bite at lunch time. Greal lunch place, if you want dinner you will have to go early becuase they close at 7 pm. Everything on the menu is good, but i do reccomend to eat fish when you are in... More