I was expecting really great things from Pierre's, especially because we ate at Morada Bay Cafe the night prior and it was excellent. Unfortunately we were not impressed. The food was not impressive and seemed to try to hard. The only part of the meal I enjoyed was dessert. Especially considering the we spent close to $200 for the two... more

I write this review as someone who had eaten at Pierre's at least six times over the past eight or so years.....The seventh trip was definitely my last. It all started when I called the restaurant over a week before I was to arrive in Islamorada and made reservations for two on a Saturday night. The individual I made the... more

What can I say but ambiance at its perfection! Pierre's has its outdoor Morada Beach Cafe set on the sand.....reminds me of world renowned Little Palm Island which I visited years ago... Steel drums playing.....table set on the sand.....sunset views over the shimmering gulf......you can't find a more romantic place! This is backed up by its formal restaurant and quasi-outdoor... more

Beautiful atmosphere as everyone has said already. However for what it offers I would prefer going next door to Morada Bay. I think it is owned by the same owners anyway. The food is a little too much. Sauce should compliment a meal not over power it. It isn't worth the money for me. But it is a nice atmosphere. more

great atmosphere, great service and great food... more

Outstanding Chef, creative French Caribbean cuisine, and wonderful bar and lounge. This is a great place for an intimate dinner or party and I have been to small and large parties here and never been disappointed. more

We found the perfect place to celebrate our wedding anniversary. Food was excellent and so was the service and atmosphere. more

After reading all the reviews and being familiar with Morada Bay next door, we decided to eat at Pierre's for our anniversary. We started with apps, and that is where we ended. They were bland and overpriced. I had the crab napolean, 2 chunks of crab with bland avocado/tomato. My husband had the fish duo, again, the fish sliced so... more

One of my best friends was married at Pierre's a few months ago. It was one of the nicest weddings I have attended. The wedding ceremony was held on the beach amidst the pending sunset, which was just beautiful. The reception followed immediately where the staff tended to the guests with multiple platters of appetizers and drinks. The food (appetizers... more