Probably the most disgusting swill in a long time. We ordered the conch fritters. These were little more than fried dough balls with the conch seriously missing in action. I very, very rarely send things back, but these went back. Didn't even care if they charged or not, it was a matter of protest. The grouper had all the flavor... more

We dined at Fogartys last year, and honestly were very dissapointed. We had hoped it was an off-night, so we gave it another try this year. The food and service were equally bland. I ordered a filet medium. It was pink inside, but oh so dry and barely warm. My wife left the "Catch of the Day" on her plate.... more

Typical American food and seafood, but a bit overpriced. I order the chicken quesadillas and the chicken didn't have any flavor, it tasted prepackaged. My boyfriend ordered a the blackened steak and he said that it was great and cooked well, but didn't taste like it was blackened. I order a Coke and they brought me Pepsi. Not a big... more

We had just watched the sunset at Mallory Square and was looking for a place for dinner. There were 4 of us and we all wanted seafood. This place looked very nice and so we decided to eat here. I had the salmon with mashed potatoes and asparagus and it was the best I have eaten and plenty of it.... more

Food was decent, but the service and pace of the meal was poor. It was nothing special and I regretted choosing this restaurant for my brother's birthday dinner. more

Really enjoyed this restaruant. The food was great and the prices were very reasonable. I only spent a day in Key West, and so I can't compare it to other places there but it really was a great place to eat. They have a child's menu that had several choices and my daughter loved the "smiley" fries. You must try... more

Fogarty's is a repeat offender of BAD FOOD and BAD SERVICE. Of course we were hoping for something much different than what we walked away with when we visited. I ordered Grouper and asked for the sauce on the side. Almost all their menu items come with cream sauce. Ask any chef the reason for massive amounts of unnecessary cream... more

nice place the sante fe chicken salad really good and big and the smoky joe's ribs really good too more

While in Key West, my husband and I ate lunch at Fogertys (Duval and Caroline). They serve local sea food, burgers, etc. in lovely outside seating. They had pipes overhead with water lightly misting some tables (it felt nice in the heat!). I got an appetizer- quesadillas, and my husband got a cheese burger and fries. The food was exceptional-... more