Really don't get all the raving reviews here! Went on the recommendation of B & B owner where we stayed. Nice atmosphere, kinda bistro like, but tables on top of each other...hard to have a conversation without neighbors hearing everything. Service average at best....ordered an app & their "signature" mushroom soup. App came, soup never did. Pointed out to server... More

The food at this restaurant is just caught fresh and well prepared. It is Key West fine dining, in a decidedly Key West way. It is not New york fine dining, but the food, wine and service are all top notch. Dont miss the hogfish here -- you wont be able to get fish like this back home.

The food is fantastic. Chef John prepares his dishes with meticulous detail and creative ingredients for a truly unique dining experience. It’s obvious that all of the food from fish to vegetables is fresh. The European influence is clear from the moment you walk in, yet it is in the heart of Old Town. The hogfish really is to out... More

What a restaurant! I could eat the entire tappas/appetozer menu, and come back the next night for a dinner. A must do when visiting key west! Order the seafood risotto and the saganaki.....Oh and the hog snapper for dinner!

My wife and I love the food in Key West, but Cafe Sole remains our favorite. Nice atmosphere and service, coupled with great food, are the reason. My persoal favorite seafood is the hard-to-find hogfish, and Cafe Sole always does a great job with it.

A tiny gem of a restaurant. When you are in Key West this is not to be missed. The atmosphere is what I pictured Key West to be. The food was meticulously prepared showed great attention to detail. The service was great. The signature Hogfish is not to be missed.

Yearly visits for 18 years to Key West. We never miss a evening at the best restaurant on the island. A foodie's heaven. Every bite of sinful pleasures. A must visit, top of our list. And we have tried many resturants, this still remains our number one.

I totally recommend the hogfish, it is light and flaky, perfectly cooked, best fish meal I had on the island. My husband had the grouper and was equally satisfied.

If you are not familiar with the restaurant, then you will wonder what the appetizer Angels on Horseback is. Cannot tell you how many folks that we have joined for dinner here and suggested this appetizer to, have come back just for this appetizer. It is unique. It is a date stuffed with garlic, wrapped in smoked bacon, with some... More