You can't see this restaurant from the street and we passed it up the first couple of days. It was great. They had a very extensive menu with pastas, pizzas and seafood. The outdoor setting was beautiful. There were huge trees with rope lighting on them. They bring wonderful, hot bread - which sold me in itself. We ate at... more

New York Pizza Cafe is a "must experience" restaurant in Key West, especially for families with small children. My husband, son and I view Key West as a second home and look so forward to dining at this hidden Italian treasure. The ambiance at night is romantic, yet child friendly. We have always been provided excellent service by the personable... more

Hidden but a great surprise. excellent pasta dishes and the dinner rolls are to die for....excellent service provided by Kamilo. Highly recommend this place! Great atmosphere and not a tourist haven. Three other couples we talked with there also raved about the food more

I can't speak to other meals but my wife and I have had several most enjoyable breakfasts here during visits to Key West. This is one of several restaurants and shops that share a quiet courtyard area just off Duval. And better still, there is a large, free parking lot just out back. Breakfast can be had here even late... more

You will find a friendly and accommodating staff that quickly serves you wonderful food. The outdoor dining is refreshing and cool, even on warm summer evenings. The prices are good and considering the portion size, an even better value! more

A very good dining experience, although stick away from their Mojito's . . . tasted of rum and soda only! However, the food was great! Adn the size of the portions! My wife is a vegetarian, so had a pasta bake. The portion is the size that we would serve for a main course for four people!!! And it tasted... more

This has been a long time favorite place of ours, and it still worth the visit. Nice sized portions, great taste at reasonable prices. The portions are not as big as they were our last visit, and we didn't get fresh cheese like we used to, and this kept it from being a 5 star experience. I don't think its... more

This place was once one of our favorites in Key West. However, the last 3 times there were all a disappointment to say the least. The reason we kept going back after the first bad experience was because it so good before and anybody can have a bad day. We had a pizza that was burned on the bottom, a... more

This pizza is absolutely fantastic. Loaded with lots of toppings and just delicious. They deliver too which is very nice. After a late night of hitting the Key West bars, you can't go wrong with a pizza from here. more