Antonia's was selected based on other on-line reviews, because I was in the mood for Italian food, and becasue from the street it looks very enticing. But it was a big disappointment. The atmosphere is very nice, which was an initial appeal. The small bar area is intimate, but the bartender was a jerk. Once seated at a table, our... more

We had lunch at Antonia's, as the only guests. The place looked deserted from the outside, even though a blackboard outside said Open for lunch. Food was very good, we had just a light frittata and a carpaccio. Service was excellent. Needless to say, no extra waiting, but our waitress also put it that bid of extra care that makes... more

We ate there twice this past week and both times the food was excellent and the service on point. We enjoyed the decor and the prices were on par with other finer dining establishments on Key West. Reservations are important....you may get lucky with a walk-in but they were turning people away both nights we dined there. more

We loved Antonia's. We visited Christmas week after meals at several other good restaurants, including Cafe Sole and Michaels. We liked Antonia's best. Our waiter was friendly and helpful, the food excellent and the prices reasonable. Save room for dessert. The coconut cream pie with amaretto is to die for! more

We went to Antonia's, because we wanted good italian food. The food WAS good, no question about that. Wine was fine also. However the service was terrible. We waited with our table EMPTY - not a bread basket, - nothing - for like 45 minutes, with our waitress serving and taking orders from the guests who came after us. She... more

We were recently in Key West and had dinner at Antonia's 2 nights. The food was excellent both nights. They have a great menu that has a number of choices including seafood, homemade pasta and beef/veal. We had homemade pasta and thought it was excellent! The wait staff was very friendly and attentive. I would definitly recommend having dinner here... more

Not cheap, but good food, elegant ambience, excellent wait staff. more

The only in my book homemade pasta on the island - not taking away from the marvelous hospitality. more

Missed the opportunity to dine at Antonias last year (went to the Opera, ughhh!) but did visit this year. Wow, had a very romantic dinner, Chicken Marsala to die for, amazing fettuccini...just a very, unrushed, delicious dinner. The very best in Italian in Key West. more