The service was great! Amazing lobster rolls! Everything is great and really fresh. We could bike to it from our b&b and we ate right outside.
My wife and I just returned from a 5 day cruise over thanksgiving. The ship stopped in Key west and since we love lobster and other seafood.We made it a point to stop at The eaton street seafood market.They served it on a wonderful toasted roll with just plain mayo, what a treat. It is located close to the historic... More
Not really a restaurant although they have limited but nice seating out front. We took full advantage of this market and the outdoor grill at our rental house. We enjoyed grilled hogfish two nights from one order, sauteed sea scallops and wonderful lobster rolls. Freshly-made mozzarella cheese and beefsteak tomatoes on toasted garlic bread made yummy snacks. Very helpful staff... More
I was so excited to try this place after reading all the reviews only to be sorely disappointed. I ordered 2 large stone crabs and it cost $28!!! Really... That's a good deal. There wasn't enough crab to call it even an appetizer. Seating outdoors... What a joke. Literally a couple of broken down benches. Won't be back.
Our cruise stopped in Key West and we needed some good seafood. We ate here based on the reviews and it did not disappoint! It's off the main tourist path but an easy walk. We had the Lobster Roll and Crab Cake sandwich and they were the best I've had. Seating is limited but it's great for carry out and... More
Stopped for lunch based on Trip Advisor reviews. Counter service. Food was good and reasonable priced. But its more of a take-out place as there were only a few seats at a counter. I would go there again and recommend this place, but for take-out.
This is fundamentally a fish market. However, they do offer a limited variety of take-outs. One of which is a fantastic lobster roll sandwich! Comprised of very little other than lobster meat, generously supplied, it compares very favorably with those we were used to when we lived in New England. The price may be a bit high for some but... More
Old town Key West this great seafood market that has everything and when I say fresh I should say catch of the day fresh. I've been ordering my fresh large Key West Pinks cocktail style from here for years. If it's a local fish they have it! They make the best Key Lime mustard sauce and their homemade cocktail sauce... More
We wanted local seafood without the restaurant trip, so we asked our cab driver where to go. He suggested Eaton's. Wow, was he right. Everything was prepared fresh and the cost was reasonable for Key West. They have an outside dining area, but we notice many people picking up go orders. The stone crab claws were wonderful. We also had... More
Never eaten lobster before and passed this little cafe/deli one evening and saw it written on the board outside so today went there for lunch - their lobster roll is amazing - if I lived here I would eat there every day but unfortunately have to go back to the UK in a couple of days - if you are... More
If you own or manage Eaton Street Seafood Market, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing