The food was amazing. And the service was outstanding. Our Server, Brian, was awesome with an adorable personality.
This restaurant is located in a more residential neighborhood, away from the hustle of Duval. The decor and setup of the restaurant is very unique. We had made a reservation for a Monday evening, which was recommended when I called there. When we arrived there were a few tables still available. We ordered the lobster mac entree as well as... More
We came because of the reviews. Sadly, I think people are over inflating their ratings. The food is good, definitely above average, and the wine selection is quite nice, but a five star experience this is not. The location is in a residential area, far, far from anything else. We sat on the porch and had a delightful server. The... More
Great location off the beaten path. We enjoyed a trio sampling of appetizers which included tomatoes and mozzarella, grilled shrimp and the infamous lobster mac and cheese. For dinner, I ordered the hogfish with banana salsa and my husband ordered two appetizers, scallops and the grilled shrimp. All exceeded expectations and I will definitely be back next time in Key... More
Off the beaten path you will find amazing places and this is by far the best! I can honestly say that I have never had anything so good! The complex culinary flavors blew me away. Down thing so simple as chicken and waffles, was by far the most complex flavors! A little spice, a little sweet, and Bam! Seriously good.... More
What a wonderful little restaurant. It is in a quiet location, has excellent food and congenial waiters - thank you Brian. The atmosphere alone is worth a visit, add gourmet like food and you have a winner. Surprisingly, this place has been open for eight years . I think once people discover it they want to keep it a secret... More
The food at this restaurant was excellent. I had mahi and my husband had red curry with shrimp. We also shared the appetizer trio which was delicious. We both wished we had ordered an entree of the Lobster Mac and Cheese! It was rich and delicious. We enjoyed the server and host, who was readily available to answer questions regarding... More
Been in south Florida for over a week. This was a terrific experience. Food was top notch.service by Micah was great. It is off the beaten path, so you want to go there for the food and service. If you want excitement, entertainment, crowds, and partying you best go someplace else.
My husband and I went here on our honeymoon....Amazing! The lobster mac & cheese is a MUST!!! I promise, we joke that we would go back to Key West just for the lobster mac & cheese! They are very friendly and help with any questions that you might have for the menu. Dessert was good too, banana bread french toast!
What a find! Spicy Tropical Stir Fry with Shrimp was amazing - a wonderland of flavors! Good wine list made pairing easy. Alberto was so charming and helpful. Overall, a fun place, quiet and sweet.
If you own or manage The Flaming Buoy Filet Co., register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing