My daughter, husband and I visited this restaurant in November. Quaint atmosphere and authentic hosts, but we found our dishes a bit tasteless. The spaetzle with cheese was rather gluey, and the schnitzel with cognac sauce was surprisingly bland. We couldn't say much for the apple cake dessert either. We wanted to like this, but we wouldn't rush back. For... more

This is a great place to eat & drink beer.When we are in Florida,we try to eat here at least twice a month.I was a pilot for years & flew to Germany more times than I could count.Now I don't have to be up all night to get there...just drive to "The Old Schnitzelhaus !!!!! more

My wife and I were staying at the Anna Maria Pirate's Den which means we had only a short stroll to reach the restaurant. We walked over on a Monday only to discover that they were closed on Monday. We returned on Tuesday at 5 PM when they open. We were the first ones there and were told that we... more

This place has better food than Germany! Great atmosphere, friendly staff, fantastic food, I love this restaurant. This is the real McCoy don't pass it up. more

Delightful smallish charming place in a strip mall but with delightful German atmosphere. German management. Usually full of German customers, too, in my experience. Impressive bar with German brews on draft. Wonderful food. Excellent Schnitzels (pork or veal) .Goulasch. On Friday, call ahead to reserve the Schweinhachsen (pork hocks, wonderfully and intensely garlicy, with Kraut and German potatoes) Rich. A... more

I love this place. Every time we go we make plans to eat here at least twice. The food is always excellent. The appetizers are incredible. I've never had a bad meal. This will always be part of our Island tradition (Anna Maria Island). more

We've been there many times now, and we've never been disappointed. Love the Swiss Schnitzel (Schnitzel with mushroom & cream, Swiss cheese) and my girlfriend likes the beef Roulade. When we go there, we have to have an appetizer (either potato pancakes or chicken livers) and a homemade dessert (try the apple strudel!!!) The food is prepared to order, the... more

Seems to be a big difference in eating alone at the bar and at a table with the family as we had a less than wonderful meal on our last trip here on vacation. Haxen and Weissbier still award winning but Schnizel ordered by the wife and daughter was dry and with little flavor. Also, a "side" order of a... more

Best German food I have had since I left Germany, and I lived in Germany for six (6) years. Real German beer and wine. The owner, Wolfgang, does seating and handles bar duties. His wife Brigitte does the cooking, and its all "home" cooking. Nothing but fantastic (phantastisch auf deutsch). I love rolladen, and Brigitte makes it just like she... more