I went to Pincher's Crab Shack on the road to Ft. Myers Beach last week and ordered their "High Roller" Crab Sandwich for $17.99. I was expecting the crabcake of my dreams..instead, I got a mushy, lukewarm cake with a piece of shell in every bite! The french fries were cold, greasy and limp and the cole slaw was served... more

Nice little local joint with pretty good seafood and a relaxed atmosphere. Big TVs, very laid back atmosphere. Service depends on your waiter or waitress...not always consistent but food is fairly consistent. Pincher Claws appetizer is our favorite. Crabs are decent when you're in the mood to get dirty. There's another Pincher's close to Fort Myers Beach with water views... more

Our party of 9 was well accomodated for, as the service was friendly and prompt. The price was on par with most other seafood restaurants I've been to, and wasn't any lower for being near the ocean as one may think or hope. The atmosphere was conducive for our table containing 4 children. The waitress was knowledgeable about the food... more

Grilled yellow tuna is a fav more

Fresh as you can get! more

My family and I have just returned from a trip to Sanibel Island and while we were off island we checked in with a local real estate office that recommended Pinchers in Fort Myers. We were originally going to buy from the fresh market at take back to our condo and decided to dine in instead. My mother-in-law had the... more

service, food, and atmosphere is ok, not the greatest more

We enjoyed dinner here. We were planning on going somewhere else, but the wait was too long so we drove up the road and found Pinchers. I would say it was a good experience. I enjoyed the atmosphere and the employees were nice and helpful. Prices are consistent with the other places we've eaten here...service was pretty good, food came... more

Food was ok, would recommed Joe's Crab Shack before Pinchers. more