Stumbled into this place late one night recently starving.. husband just had to have italian.. he promptly ordered the special dish with all the seafood, and was delighted with it, as for me and my family, we were disappointed not to recieved some type of garlic butter rolls prior to and with our dinner, only a store bought plain roll?... more

My husband and I were looking for a simple restaurant to have a late dinner in on our second night in Amelia Island. It was Easter Sunday and we had brunch so we weren't hungry at our usual dinner time. I was reluctant to head into town on Easter Sunday at 9pm thinking everything would be closed. To our delight... more

My wife and I had a authentic delicious, fresh and hot meal that was truly Italian. The price was reasonable. The service was the best. The owner and chef, Mario, brought our food out which was freshly prepared, greeted us and treated us like one of his family members. No complaints at all. If you are wanting great Italian with... more

If you really enjoy Italian food, a bit of ambience, good but not intrusive service, this may not be your place. If you are visiting Amelia Island, you might be better off trying some other place. This place is just average with an above average price, more

we go to italy every year...and this restaurant is very authentic in its cooking...the ambience is very nice ... candle lit very good wine choices !! homemade pasta that is very good. seafood is the best... and we also find the sauces to be the best we have had... very good recipes... a desssert tray with beautiful italian pastry desserts... more

Excellent service, delicious garlic infused stuffed crab, veal marsala to die for and a great italian dining room ambiance. Well worth it. more

Disappointed-food overpriced We have dined at Pompeo's several times. Great location, good service, however, food was very disappointing. Special entree was overpriced-$27.95 for 3 tough shrimp on a wooden skewer, 2 tablespoons of overcooked vegetables, & a very thin piece of white fish floating in butter. The entree was to be grilled medley of seafood. When we asked to could... more

We were very tired of seafood and found this place. We really enjoyed the food. They had the best fettuccini I have had in a long time. They also had escargo. The food prep took it time, so don't be in a hurry. The chicken picatta was very good as well. We would visit again. more

Three of us ate here for dinner one night several months ago and we found it to be just OK for the prices they charge. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here. more