consistently great food; nice selection, with good specials. I have eaten here dozens of times and always had a great dinner.
We have eaten many times at Gelato, and each experience has been extraordinary. This week we needed last minute catering for my brother's funeral. Ryan and his staff could not have been more accommodating. Specific dietary restrictions, delivery and set up while we were all out of the house, follow up, etc. When we ran out of food, the staff... More
We ordered several sandwich trays for a luncheon following a funeral. Despite a thorough initial meeting, email, and a phone call the day before the lunch, two of the four selections were made incorrectly. The people who delivered the trays were nice enough and called the restaurant to see what they could do to fix it. After plenty of apologies,... More
We were taken here by friends and had a really good meal. We were seated in a private room, and were waited on by extremely attentive, professional waiters. The food was served promptly and was delicious. I had a special request on the menu and it was no problem at all for them, and were very obliging. I would go... More
I've had 6 or 7 meals here, but the most recent one was the best. Creamy pasta with salmon and shrimp. Maybe I have a weak spot for that dish, but they did a particularly good job with it. The wait staff was super, and the prices reasonable. I always have a good meal here.
We used Ryan last week for an event we hosted for a group of physicians here in Newark. We had such a great experience we booked them for our next event in November. Ryan and his team exceeded my expectations with their excellent service and delicious food.
Our family of 4 (2 adults, 2 teens) used to eat at Cafe Gelato a couple times a year, but after our last couple experiences we wont be back. Our last dining experience included being ignored by our waitress, despite the fact the restaurant wasnt very busy, however she was attentive to other tables. I guess she ignored us because... More
I've been to Cafe Gelato for dinner, but never before for lunch. Good prices and good choices. Service was very good. We sat outside on Main Street and people watched (it was checkin day for UD freshmen).
My husband and I went to dinner for his birthday on a recent Saturday night at 7:00. I have been to Caffe Gelato many ,many times over the years since the first year they opened. Generally the food and service are very good, something I expect because they are not inexpensive but have always been worth it. We were very... More
We had dinner and had a much better experience than our last visit (when we dined with a group of friends). The food was delicious, no mix-ups on our order. We enjoyed a salad (which we shared), our entrees and desserts. Service was smooth! We'll hope for the same good food and service when we visit again in the future.
If you own or manage Caffe Gelato, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing