The pizza crust is absolutely the best! Kids loved the sausage pizza and the "works"! The wood fired oven is so cool. Husband tried the calamari. It was great, too. Lightly breaded and the marinara was quite tasty. I had the chef's salad, it was huge. I needed a take home box! The restaurant is small and very local. Loved... More

We've eaten pizza here several times and each time the sauce and crust were excellent. The only problem is that their Margherita pizza is not a traditional Margherita pizza with crushed tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil. Instead they make it (as they advertise) with tomato sauce and a couple of pieces of basil. It tastes good, but it's not a true... More

I am so happy I found this place because it reminds me of a place I used to go to back home. The pizza is wood-fired In an old-school style oven. You can see the oven and fire when you walk through the door. It is deliciously gourmet and it's better than any other pizza I've ever had. I had... More

The service was top notch, and a family friendly atmosphere. We were greeted and seated promptly with a smile. We started off with wonderful appetizers of potato skins and onion rings. Next was the woodfire pizza that was to die for! I highly recommend the Vito pizza. It was recommened to me by the waiter and it was the best... More

In all seriousness, Mr P's has customer service down to an art. It was evident in the greeting of every customer by the Mr P's team. They adjusted from serving an entire high school track team to managing the Friday dinner rush and the takeout flow without losing that personal touch. The pizza was among the best I've eaten. Just... More

Fantastic food, serve by an extremely friendly waitress at a very reasonable price. We go to the Lewes(Rehobeth DE) area at least 2-4 times a year and my daughters insist we go to Mr.P's as soon as we get there every time.

Just moved to Lewes and went to Mr P's based on other Tripadvisor reviews. Owner was really friendly and helpful. Wood-fired pizza was good. Pizza was thick and doughy. We prefer thin crust wood-fired pizza. Definitely will go back and recommend to others. Don't take credit cards - ATM inside restaurant.

Was going to Ocean City with wife and daughter and decided to make a pit-stop at Mr P's Pizza. We decided on a pizza with pepperoni and sausage (i believe it was called a san giorgo) and a buffalo chicken sandwich. While my wife and daughter really liked the food, I LOVED IT (esp the pizza)!!!!!!! Wish there was a... More

Stopped in on the way back from the beach on an aborted weekend away - jellyfish attack :-( The food and service helped put a "brief" smile on our little girl's face. We promised to stop by next summer under better circumstances - kids absolutely loved the pizza !