It doesn't look like much on the outside, but the food was excellent and far beyond expectations. The menu was varied and focused on seafood dishes. My wife and I selected the miso glazed halibut and the duck with scallops. Both dishes were prepared perfectly. The appetizer of fried okra was a pleasant surprise. The waiter could have been a... more

We had a very nice time, the food was good and the waitstaff friendly. Would definitely go back. more

Our first trip to Stonington was great across the board. The Water Street Cafe was recommended by the Inn we were staying at, and very busy when we arrived. They were quick to acknowledge us, and find us a spot to wait for a table. Our waitress, Erin, was WAY too busy for one waitress and handled with the greatest... more

Another local favorite. Small but good. more

I go here from time to time, and it is always good food. The other comments about the service is really about the popularity of the place. It gets crowded, because it has consistently good eats. Love the steak with shropms on a salad on spuds with cheese on top! more

We gave the Water Street Cafe another chance, The food was great, the service wasn"t. After our order, our waitress disappeared, never checking in with us. We had to signal another waitress for our drinks. Bread? of course not. Our waitress did not seem to care and was very unfriendly. It is really a shame, as the food is very... more

on wednesday dec.10th went to eat my husband and i we ordered seared tuna and london broil my husband tried tuna said it didnt taste good so i said ill eat it at 21.00 i wasnt going to leave it. time thier was 630 to 745 i went home went to bed awoke at 11:45 with bad pains in stomach... more

Good food but difficult to get service. Not a regular? You will feel snubbed. more

love more