Good pizza - dough is light. The Panini sandwich is my favorite though! Go visit before or after the movie theater
Best pizza ever! We pre-ordered our pizzas to cook at home - they were ready to go when we got there and took them home to bake - they were delicious!!
Excellent reviews, but it was empty on a Monday afternoon and I had to wait 15 min despite calling in the most basic order: 2 slices of plain. They didn't tell me until later they'd dropped a piece. I didn't have time to wait another 15 so I never got to try it. Won't return.
Taste is subjective. The last reviewer didn't even say what she ordered but instead offends others who haven't had a bad experience. We were delighted with our choice of home delivery pizza to cook at our leisure- we ordered the 3-meat with regular crust. The directions were straightforward, it cooked perfectly. The crust came out great- not an easy thing... More
We went out to Edwards to ctach a movie while staying in Vail and decided to walk around the shopping center to grab a late lunch after the movie. So glad we found Old Forge! They serve pizza by the slice so I was able to get thin crust and my fiance got thick. It hit the spot. The guys... More
Convenient location, the gentleman taking our order was very personable. I have never dined in here, but the dining room is inviting. These folks seem like they really care about their business and customers.
My husband and I went in to order some pizza for dinner. It was quite cold outside and they had the door wide open and it was freezing inside. There were no other customers in the restaurant but I guess they were still too busy to take our order. We were totally ignored for 10+ minutes. They saw us standing... More
If you own or manage Old Forge Pizza co, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing