Great sauce, lots of topping and if you ask for the crust well done, you can imagine you're back east.
Possibly the best New york style pizza in the area. We have enjoyed their food ever since they opened up. Whether we eat in or take out the service is always top notch. We have never had a bad experience.
Great and cheap pizza. We attend here every Friday. Large screens from every angle. Food is awesome and you can build your own.
Cali doesn't do great pizza like NY and this is by far the closes place we have found to it. This place is truly a gem, costumer service is not that great but the pizza is! If you like NY style pizza, give it a try!!
We're from Boston originally and we still go there ;) Seriously, Celestino's has the best pizza in the area. The staff is great and you can hang out and enjoy the pizza, wine and beer for as long as you want.
I am from NY..you never find good pizza in Calif..but I did here..Just go you will love it!! The service is great and the food is yummy..I am so glad I found Celestinos!!
If you like thin crust, New York style pizza this is the place to go. Never disappoints. just great pizza!
Celestino's is as close to New York style pizza as you are going to find in Rocklin California. Tried many of the places recommended to me when I first moved out to CA from upstate NY and none of them came close to real NY style pizza. Then I found this place. It was like a little taste of home.... More
My wife and I grew up in Brooklyn. Celestino's pizza is the real deal if you like thin crust pizza. The crust was the right combination of crisp and slightly chewy. The sauce is just right, neither too sweet or strong. We prefer plain cheese pizza. Celstino's uses quality mozzarella. Our last vist was a couple of weeks ago. We've... More
Despite the tagline, this pizza didn't remind me of Brooklyn. The crust was not up to par. Very average to less than average tasting pizza.
If you own or manage Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing