We thought this restaurant was a little overpriced for the quality of its food and lack of ambience. It seemed tired - the decor, the staff, the menu. Four members of the staff sat at the bar on their break while we were having lunch. Leaving space for paying customers seems more appropriate. The place could benefit from some spiffing... more

Stopped here for dinner on recommendation and was not disappointed. Very good local seafood at a good price. more

We were on our way home from a tour of the Northwest and stopped overnight in Eureka. I choose Cafe Waterfront because of reviews here. We were not disappointed and found the prices fair. We shared a dozen local oysters and each had a half a bucket of clams with a salad and bread. Including drinks the tab was $80.... more

I had just parked in the free all-day parking for Old Town Eureka and was craving some grilled oysters, when I walked by a sign just around the corner that said "Oyster Bar," and that was it! I went in and had a wonderful lunch at Cafe Waterfront. I had spicy shrimp bisque (to die for!!!!), sourdough bread, 6 or... more

I live in Eureka and have eaten at the Cafe Waterfront literally dozens of times during the years. So my comments are not based on a one time visit, but on the composite of all these visits. The Building is very historic and the restaurant is very attractive inside with some great art work and stained glass. The seating is... more

Great oyster burgers! the best. Full bar, small room but very popular. Always fresh fish on the menu. Directly across from the boardwalk, in old town. Close to shops and nice places to walk. more

I've been to this restaurant a number of times...always hoping it will live up to the hype....always disappointed. The building itself is adorable, and the mural inside is beautiful. Lots of personality in this restaurant, with a nice view of Humboldt Bay. Unfortunately, the food is just mediocre. The clam chowder has more white flour than clams, the prawns and... more