We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Write a Review

23 reviews from our community

Visitor rating
Rating summary
Date | Rating
  • English first
  • Any
English first
Top Contributor
77 reviews 77 reviews
41 restaurant reviews
53 helpful votes 53 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed November 1, 2014 via mobile

Went here for lunch with a friend. My friend had a personal pizza which looked delicious & a salad. I had the chicken parm & a salad. It was great. Pleasant efficient waitress. The only downside was the temperature of the restaurant was chilly. Had trouble taking my coat off & I had a sweater on. A lot of other... More 

Was this review helpful? Yes
Senior Contributor
23 reviews 23 reviews
17 restaurant reviews
13 helpful votes 13 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed September 1, 2014

They have a large menu. Two in our party ordered salads, the other two hot dinner entrees. They also have Gluten free items. The salads were large & fresh. One in our party ordered spaghetti & meatball parmesan. It looked good, but the friend said it didn't taste good. I had chicken with angel hair pasta and lemon butter sauce.... More 

Was this review helpful? Yes
15 reviews 15 reviews
13 restaurant reviews
5 helpful votes 5 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed August 26, 2014

I have eaten at My Tomato Pie several times over the past few months. This has given me the opportunity to try several menu items. All have been consistently delicious. This is a good sized family restaurant whose menu leans toward well loved Italian cuisine. The pasta dishes are good, as are the pizzas. I have yet to have a... More 

Was this review helpful? Yes
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Senior Contributor
28 reviews 28 reviews
14 restaurant reviews
7 helpful votes 7 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed July 12, 2014

Went to a rehearsal dinner here and it was very tasty. Got the traditional buffalo items including wings, pizza and beef on weck. Maybe I haven't had it in a while but I ate a ton of food and enjoyed it very much. Don't be deceived by the out side of the place, once you are in it feels more... More 

Was this review helpful? Yes
Buffalo, New York
Senior Contributor
36 reviews 36 reviews
22 restaurant reviews
19 helpful votes 19 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed May 31, 2014

My Tomato Pie is a great place for casual dining ! The pizza is delicious ! The tomato soup is the best ! And save room for peanut butter pie! Service is friendly, prices are good and food is great!

Was this review helpful? Yes
Ithaca, New York
Top Contributor
83 reviews 83 reviews
62 restaurant reviews
25 helpful votes 25 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed May 26, 2014

My husband says, the tomato soup was the best part of his meal! I had the zesty chicken and it was awesome! Loved it! There were 8 of us having dinner-varied taste, interests and we all loved it! we were actually a little hesitant but it was a good suggestion and we would return if back in the area again...they... More 

Was this review helpful? Yes
Buffalo, New York
Senior Contributor
35 reviews 35 reviews
25 restaurant reviews
26 helpful votes 26 helpful votes
2 of 5 stars Reviewed October 22, 2013 credit card Amex Card Member Review

For me, the most part of a good pizza and/or sauce is the sauce. I can confidently say that they have one of the worse pizza and pasta sauces I've ever had. I also tried to Eggplant ad it was rather salty.

Was this review helpful? Yes
District of Columbia
Top Contributor
128 reviews 128 reviews
74 restaurant reviews
38 helpful votes 38 helpful votes
3 of 5 stars Reviewed October 14, 2013

This place was recommended by my hotel. It is a locally owned restaurant. I ordered a personal pizza. Meh. The crust was very thick and almost tasted like it came out of the microwave. We also ordered Fried Green Tomatoes. Ummm...pass on those. Too much cornmeal batter and friend too hard. The people were really nice though and some of... More 

Was this review helpful? Yes
Syracuse, New York
17 reviews 17 reviews
14 restaurant reviews
6 helpful votes 6 helpful votes
5 of 5 stars Reviewed September 19, 2013

We often come to My Tomato Pie during our monthly visits to see family in Buffalo, and the food is always delicious. My sons - 10 and 12 and my husband are always happy with their selections. I brought my mother and my 92 year old aunt during our last visit, and they were thrilled. We all had the salads... More 

Was this review helpful? Yes
Buffalo, NY
Top Contributor
72 reviews 72 reviews
51 restaurant reviews
16 helpful votes 16 helpful votes
4 of 5 stars Reviewed July 30, 2013

This restaurant has great food, great prices and good service. My teenage grandson picked this restaurant for the homemade mac & cheese. I had a salad. They have fabulous salads (my friend says they are addictive). I also like the Panini which I have ordered on other occasions.

Was this review helpful? Yes

Travelers who viewed My Tomato Pie also viewed


Been to My Tomato Pie? Share your experiences!

Write a Review Add Photos & Videos

Additional Information about My Tomato Pie

Address: 3085 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14226-1910
Phone Number: 716-838-0969
Location: United States  >  New York (NY)  >  Amherst
Open Hours:
Sunday 11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Monday 11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Thursday 11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Friday 11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Saturday 11:00 am - 10:30 pm
Average Prices: USD 0 - 20
Cuisine: Italian

Owners: What's your side of the story?

Register now for free — and start getting automatic notification of new reviews, responding to traveler feedback, adding new photos to your listing and much more.

Manage your listing

Questions & Answers

Questions? Get answers from My Tomato Pie staff and past visitors.
Posting guidelines
Typical questions asked:
  • Do you have gluten-free options?
  • Is there a dress code?
  • Do you allow dogs on the outdoor patio?