I really wanted a good steak. I was going to go to Bobby Flay's (also in the Borgata) but there were some questionable reviews there. Sometimes you can read through the negative ones when people are just pissed or whatever. That said, I thought the service was very good and attentive at least for me. Drinks were very expensive. I... More

This steak house is high class and be ready to spend over $100 for a meal for three (not including drinks,desert, or tip). After saying that, let me say it was the BEST meal we have ever had as of yet! We ordered the Porterhouse steak for two, (there was more than enough for three) with garlic mash-potatoes and saute... More

No, but their plates look like they come from Texas! I ordered the prime rib with sautéed mushrooms and onion. OMG! It was SCRUMP-TIOUS and HUGE! It cut like butter and melted in your mouth. Every time I cut into it the jus poured out of it making it even tastier. I put a small piece of meat on my... More

My husband took me here for a birthday dinner. We didn't have reservations (highly recommend making one though) however they were able to accommodate us at the "Kitchen bar". We had fun watching the preparation and the amazing food. We had Lobster, Filet, Kitchen Salad and the Roasted peppers and mozzarella. Everything was amazing...

We liked everything. If you ever go be sure to order the Chef's Special Bread as soon as you sit down. Toasted towers of Italian Bread nestled in a pink creamy Parmesan sauce for dipping. I'd go back there just for this item. My wife ordered Three Colossal Shrimp and I ordered the Grilled Bacon (in a maple syrup sauce)... More

Elegant, great service, superb food presentation and entrees. I was with a group of 8. I ordered the sea bass which was melt in your mouth amazing. The appetizers were very large so could be shared by a few, as well as the sides. The little touches like iced tea served in a glass on a little silver tray and... More

I absolutely abhor Atlantic City-- However, I find myself speaking at conventions and obviously must find restaurants when I Stay-- Most of the steak houses and other establishments are awful--I was surprised to find a truly great steakhouse experience at the Old homestead--The menu was quite typical-- I ordered a classic iceberg wedge- which was fine But I pondered and... More

Some of the following are just minor comments but our main issue was the food. Made 7:30pm reservation and called at 5:30 from hotel room to request an earlier seating if possible. Got a 6:00 time reso and arrived on time. The time change wasn't noted on our arrival but we were still seated. It has to be the reason... More

Went on 5/7/13 . I had the Gotham Rib 34 oz. My wife had the 18oz Filet Mignon. Both were above excellent, perfectly cooked as per our request. service was good. No complaints whatsoever. I normally prefer Ruth Chris Steakhouse but these steaks were exceptionally good bringing them up a notch in my ratings. All the fat was on the... More