We had a great time at this restaurant. the service was outstanding and the food was very good (may have been excellent, we juist didn't have much of it) I'd love to get back there again. more

The menu here is varied and has some local foods. food was great, as was the service and friendly attitude. We found the atmosphere attractive and a nice change from the ordinary. more

We were the 1st table seated for the day when they opened at 11:30 AM on a Saturday. For being the only table occupied in the place, service was very slow. My husband and I had sandwiches - he loved his turkey and cheese on a bulkie but my turkey club was nothing special for the price we paid. They... more

Usually a decent spot for an average meal in a casual atmosphere, but the service was so bad that the mediocre food could not make up for it. The server's energy was nothing but of anger and impatience, we felt rushed and unwelcomed the entire time. Our entrees came at the same time as our appitizers and the check was... more

Most restaurants on Nantucket are pricy and elegant, but sometimes you want delicious food in a really relaxed atmosphere with a reasonable price. There is pleanty to choose from, and there's always a lively scene. It is packed every time we go, and be sure to go around the corner if it's a nice night to sit on the patio.... more

Reliable is a good way to describe this popular restaurant on Nantucket. Brotherhood of Thieves has been around for ten or more years now and has remained popular as a somewhat moderately priced place for simple dining. The burgers are quite good and are accompanied by curly fries and all the fixings. The chowder and lobster bisque are wonderful and... more

My wife and I grabbed a casual dinner at Brotherhood of Thieves when we were on the island this past weekend. The food was good, large portion size, and ambience were all positives, whereas the noise and proximity of other diner's tables to our own were the only negatives. Definitely worth a try for the burgers and fries. more

We ate a late lunch one afternoon so were not very hungry at dinner time. We ducked into this restaurant for a lite dinner, got salads and thoroughly enjoyed them. The salads (I got the FIELD-GATHERED ORGANIC GREENS and my companion got the CRANBERRY NUT CHICKEN SALAD) were more than generous and were beautiful. A mixture of beautiful greens, mesclun... more

It's becoming a tradition of sorts to grab lunch at the Brotherhood on our arrival day and then to end our trip with a stop here as well. They always delight! more