I loved the shrimp egg breakfast with potatoes. At the view and service were also excellent. I got great pictures of a pelican that landed on a post right by the bar.
Great atmosphere, good drink selection and fantastic service. It was the best overall meal on our trip. Not fine dinning but a good place to kick back.
I dinned at fish tails last night with my family and had a great time. The fish was fresh and delicious. Great rare seared tuna, good native snapper, and fresh oysters. That plus good cocktails made gor a gun evening. Our server michelyn (hope I didn't butcher her name) wsd friendly and knowledgeable.
Seared tuna, oysters and fresh snapper—sounds like quite a feast! Thanks for making us a part of your trip, and for the fabulous review. See you next time you're in St. Thomas! Cheers, Reggie Poe and Kelley Olive, Owners More
We had an awesome breakfast here one morning and came back for drinks one evening. Nice people. The marina view was nice too.
Thanks for starting the day with us! It's hard to go wrong with that beautiful view, so we're glad you got to see it in the evening as well. Hope to have you back next time you're in St. Thomas—we'll have a drink ready for you! Regards, Reggie Poe and Kelley Olive, Owners More
Fish Tails is located with a view of the Vessup Bay/Harbor. There is pay parking next to Fish Tails or across the street behind the bank. As you walk in, you will notice the patio bar and dining area. The main dining area was reserved for an event, so we sat at the bar area. The service was average. We... More
We'd never want any of our guests to leave feeling hungry, so it's upsetting that you did. We wish that we had been able to offer more suggestions for you and your party, and we'll be sure to remember that for the future. Thanks for that feedback, and please let us know if you have any further comments—our guests deserve... More
We ate at Fish Tails for dinner the last night of our trip. Our waiter was superb and our meals were delicious. My wife had the whole lobster special and I had one of the fresh catch fish selections. The seating is right on the water. The place was really busy, but our service was still very good.
Fresh seafood right on the water—it doesn't get more St. Thomas than that! Thanks for making us a part of your trip, and please stop by and see us next time you're in town! Regards, Reggie Poe and Kelley Olive, Owners More
First time visiting virgin islands and st thomas. Came with a friend to celebrate my birthday week. The atmosphere was great. Ended up sitting at the bar and enjoying some college football. The bartender becca was awesome. Really helpful and had tips for our first visit on the island. Also a plus that she was gorgeous. The food was a... More
Thanks for making us a part of the celebration, Antony! Sounds like our crew made you feel at home, and our drinks did, too! :) Glad you enjoyed your visit. Come back and see us next time you're in STI! Cheers, Reggie Poe and Kelley Olive, Owners More
We ate here twice for dinner on our trip. The fresh fish is always excellent and my husband loves the caribbean lobster. The waitstaff is so friendly and helpful. The seating is outside and covered, but right on the water.
So glad you were able to visit us twice during your trip, Mary! Of course, we can't blame you and your husband for craving that Caribbean Lobster—it's addictive! Thanks for making us a part of your vacation, and be sure to join us next time you're in town. Regards, Reggie Poe and Kelley Olive, Owners More
Ask any local in St. Thomas what their favorite restaurant is, and they will probably send you here. At least that's what they did for us! The food was good and drinks were really good. We didn't have any problems with service, but we did come on a slower night.
You're too kind, Amy! Glad our regulars steered you in our direction. We can't wait to have you back again next year—or sooner! :) Cheers, Reggie Poe and Kelley Olive, Owners More
We went for dinner here the first night of our stay on St. Thomas. I asked for a fried catfish sandwich, I received a grilled catfish sandwich. We also ordered a catfish filet dinner and that is exactly what we received, a little piece of catfish filet on a plate for $18. I understand that catfish isn't their specialty but... More
Although we're happy to hear that everyone was warm and welcoming, we wish that your server had been able to make better recommendations for you. Still, we want our guests to be blown away by our dishes, and we apologize for falling short. We'll discuss this with our team to make sure we're doing everything we can for our guests,... More
If you own or manage Fish Tails Bar and Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing