We went to enjoy the sunset and had a great dinner to boot. The restaurant overlooks Turtle Cove from up on the hill. So the view of the sunset was great. I had the tuna which was cooked perfectly and an appetizer of salmon. My daughter also had the tuna and the tuna tartar as an app. She's a tuna... More

I liked the food. The service timing was passable. The attitude of the servers left something to be desired. No personality and therefore, no atmosphere.

The vista from Magnolia's is wonderful, but we were disappointed in the reception we received when we first arrived and with the food. The fish was overcooked and the remainder of the dish had little taste. Given the prices of the meal, I was expecting more. Perhaps we caught the restaurant on an off night.

Went with a group of friends and got to try a few things. The tuna in soy and ginger sauce might be the best thing that has ever touched my lips. One of my friends had the lamb chops which were apparently so good he wouldn't share. We honestly didn't have a bad dish among the six of us, and... More

We walked up the hill from our condo to dine here one evening. It is mostly outside seating so bring a jacket in case you get chilly. It was quite windy the night we were there but that didn't deter us from taking in the breathtaking view and watching the sunset and the boats coming in for the evening. Their... More

We joined our friends for a birthday celebration dinner at Magnolia and admittedly we had high expectations from all of the reviews as well as the recommendation of our villa hosts. Got there for sunset cocktails and started off the evening by truly enjoying the view and atmosphere on the outside deck over martinis. A couple of us had the... More

Got a seat by the railing before sunset....of course....had reservations. Started off with escargot and then had the rare pepper tuna as a main course. It was delicious and then we topped off dinner with Banoffee pie.

It was a great & enjoyable evening and the view & service could not have been better. The appetizers and drinks were very good but the main dishes were like cafeteria food.

Three of us had 7:00 pm reservations, we were hoping for a great sunset but clouds foiled our plan. However, the view was still great. I had the goat cheese appetizer, it was very good. Two of us had filet mignon ($34) and the other had the pistachio encrusted chicken. The beef was excellent. I tried a bite of the... More