I am not following the positive reviews here at all. Yes, the personell is friendly (which you should expect anyways) and yes, the lobby looks nice. Besides that, the hotel is old and the rooms are so ridiculously small that there is no room for a suitcase or anything. The bed was extremely uncomfortable, the heat did not work at... More

This hotel was just okay. We booked for one night via Priceline, so of course we got the smallest room with one double bed. This was the smallest room I've stayed in in NYC. Even with just the double bed, it was super tiny. The bathroom was a decent size though. The hotel loby is really nice. It is an... More

This was the Hotel Seville, and Marriot has taken over the property. The lobby is a treat to the eye, the rooms so-so. We were upgraded to a corner Executive King, overlooking Madison Ave. The room was large but rather plain. The bell staff continues to be great at all Marriott properties and this group is no exception. I can't... More

This hotel is managed by Marriott so you can expect many things to be done right. Room was small but adequate. Beds were comfortable, temperature control worked properly, was quiet at night, towels were plentiful and of good quality. We had some minor issues at check-in but nothing that wasn't easily solved. Because New York is New York the extra... More

Quick check in, helpful and polite staff, concierge very helpful. Room small but what we Expected for New York. Restaurant expensive didn't eat there but plenty of other places within 5mins. Good location and Madison Park just down the block.

We booked a standard room through an agent and felt like that's what we got. Some have mentioned the small space in the standard's and that is very accurate. However we were happy enough to stay for four nights as waffle robes and Molton Brown products were a nice touch and we didn't think we'd be in the room much... More

If you want an OLD hotel with character that is close to the subway then you will be happy with your stay here. This was my first time staying at this hotel and I would not stay again for a few reasons. The room was TINY even for 2 people. The door pretty much touched the bed when we opened... More

THANK you Marriott and the staff of the Carlton - officially my favorite hotel!!! We only stayed one night due to the fact that the wedding we were attending and the Gramercy wouldn't extend our wedding rate for an extra night. I wish we could have spent our entire trip with the Carlton! On arrival the front desk was pleased... More

I had the pleasure of staying at the Carlton the weekend of my daughter's wedding (5/28/13). Fortunately, we got a special rate. OK - obviously a joyous occasion - truly! But the stay at the Carlton just made it all even more enjoyable. The location was convenient for all festivities. When Bill and I arrived - after a 6 1/2... More