I booked this hotel through Priceline and was pleased with the ~$200/night rate. The location was fine, but everythingelse was horrific. When we checked in, an elderly gentleman kept talking to my sister while I was at the front desk. The front desk clerk said to stay away from him. Comforting. Apparnetly, this hotel is also a residential hotel, which... more

Just back from a weekend trip to New York. Was recommended this as a 3-4 star hotel with 1800 Hotels. Rooms tiny one double bed with no room to move. Very stuffy by day and worse by night. We were offered an upgrade for $60.00 a night. 1800 hotels pushed this hotel to me. While it was centrally located it... more

I have booked this hotel through Priceline.com, looking for something near Times Square. We tried to check in at 1 pm, hoping they they will have a room for us, but they didn't. They told us that we can leave our luggage there, which we did (after waiting for 15 min for a person who was in charge of the... more

I also was disappointed to have Priceline send me here. I ended up spending just under $200 for the night, including taxes. The room I got was on the tenth floor facing the interior courtyard. The room was pretty clean but it was badly dated. The hotel, if it were done right, might be something like the Algonquin. A real... more

I was pretty upset to land this hotel through Priceline (mostly because I wanted a 3*, which this hotel is generally considered a 2-2.5* establishment, but that's another subject altogether), particularly after I read numerous negative reviews. Fortunately, the case against the hotel was overstated--the Jolly Madison wasn't really bad at all. I stayed in a standard room, which is... more

As usual the reviews had me frightened and as usual those fears were completed unwarranted. I got a great rate via priceline but priceline bookings only allow for 2 twin beds. However, the front desk clerk was exceptionally nice to us and switched us to a room with 1 bed as it was our anniversary - and at no additional... more

Hotel is located on 38th & Madison. Great rate. Friendly staff! Anthony greeted us at the front desk and was very friendly and helpful. Room was small but very comfortable for a weekend in the city. Room was quiet. Moonstruck on Madison Diner across the street was good for breakfast at 6am on a Saturday . 10 minute walk to... more

My daughter and I arrived for a girls get-a-way on September 26th. We arrived at Penn Station and walked to the hotel. Easy to find. We had breakfast at the Moonstruck diner (right across the street) which was recommended by others on line. Wonderful food, great price for NYC. We knew to ask for an upsell at check-in. We reserved... more

Qutie a nice hotel, the room was a good size but it could have been a bit cleaner. Really good location. The service was ok. more