I guess the price I paid ($200 per night) was worth the location, being close to various subway stations and in the middle of mid-town, however, the room was pretty depressing. Windows looked out to *nothing* at all - there was no sunlight so it was like being in solitary confinement.. depressing to say the least. The TV is perched... more

This hotel is a gem among giants. The staff is great, the rooms are nice, and the location is perfect. The hotel was not what I expected, it was great surprise. more

I have been staying at City Club since it first opened, and I still love this hotel. As it is a boutique hotel, I love the décor, the lights on dimmer switches, and friendly customer service. I do miss the Hermes bath products, but the home baked cookies every night make up for it! I call it my "home away... more

I stayed at City Club in Dec 2009, and the very first day I went to check in they gave me some story about having to "close down a block of rooms" and that they'd have to send me to another hotel down the street and they'd take care of the charges. So okay, I dragged all of my luggage... more

I loved the style and decor of the hotel but it was a tad to small. Very nice room and bathroom, but not a lot of storage space. I understand that hotel rooms in NYC might be small, but this roomed seemed very small for the list price. No coffee maker which was a huge disappointment, but a delicious cookie... more

This hotel is best for a romantic getaway type of deal. I'd give this 4 stars were it not for the loud cracking noise from the heating system. The regular rate is $200+ for a petite, which is overpriced unless you can get an upgrade to a queen or larger. If you are into sleek, dark, masculine, and more modern/trendy... more

This is a boutique hotel just a stone's throw from Time's Square. It is on a lovely, somewhat quiet street next to some beautiful historic properties..The Algonquin, The Iroqouis are next door. There is a large Brooks Brothers store a few doors down. If you are looking for an inexpensive place to drop after a night of Time's square or... more

we forgot our wallet back home in toronto but had plenty of cash and no credit cards on us. When we arrived to the hotel the manager at the front desk told us that we need a credit card and that he could not bend the rules for us. After pleading with him for ten minutes he said he will... more

Travelled for a long awaited weekend break to NY with my husband. We flew into Newark Airport and got the express but to Bryant Square which was only very short walk to the Hotel. Staff were very friendly on arrival and stored our bags until we could check in. Room was lovely, very clean and the bed was exceptionally comfy.... more