I have stayed at 1871 house twice, and I also sent my son there when he visited NYC alone to interview for internships. To me it's like staying at a friend's house while he or she is away. The hot water and the internet can both be unreliable, but the rooms are big and clean, and they have hardwood floors... more

I was a guest at the 1871 House May 19-22, 2009 with my German friends. I called to ask if I could come about 2 hours earlier to buy flowers for the apartment, I was told yes. They were holding the credit card info of my friend. When I arrived they would not let me in, saying, "they couldn't just... more

Stayed for 9 days in February. I’d pored over the photos on the website and debated whether to stay in the Mission suite but finally plumped for the Parlor. On my visit to New York the previous May I had passed by the premises whilst checking out the area. As I stood sheltering from the rain, the front door opened... more

1871 House is perfect for those who are in the city to "see the city". The price is quite reasonable and the rooms are comfortable. It was very clean. I spent a long weekend in February with three other friends, staying in the Lexington Suite. Thought was put into the decor; you feel as if you are in another country-... more

1871 House January 2008 We stayed for 5 nights in this lovely place. We had a great time. Leon helped us a lot and tried to arrange our stay as we had a lot of problems with our flight (Aerolineas Argentinas). We had paid for more nights but due to a strike in Buenos Aires, we arrived to new york... more

I booked at the last minute, having struggled to find any room in midtown for less than $600 a night--and was so glad I ended up here! The 1871 house feels less like a hotel than a private home--YOUR private home. Just walking through the (unmarked) door transports you to a more gracious time. My room, the Garden Room, was... more

The Garden room was stunning. What a treat to have a private garden outside one's room in bustling NYC. The decor and restoration of the property is SMASHING. It was elevating to stay in such elegant surroundings and made our business stay fun. Be sure to confirm the shower and bathing arrangements for your room, ours was very European and... more

What a rare find! The 1871 House was the perfect refuge in a big and crazy city! The Inn is appointed with beautiful antiques, including an awesome wood bed and leather settee. The quality linens, marble bath and finishing touches were classic and tasteful. The inn keeper provided great info on area restaurants and shopping, and gave me assurances that... more

I agree with IRISDENMARK - the 1871 House is in such a great location and is very comfortable but the service is appalling. We got the feeling that we were the free loading relatives who had over stayed their welcome rather than paying guests. Staff avoid eye contact with you in case you ask them for anything and when you... more