I've had the misfortune of staying at the American Eagle Inn more than once for the simple reason that every place else in town was sold out for University events. This time, I was put in a room next to the exit door which opened to the parking lot. All night long, the door slammed as people came in and... more

The only really bad thing about this hotel is that you cannot make reservations online. The rooms are well kept and clean. The staff was courteous and accomidating in every way. I had forgotten to tell them that I needed a handicapped room when I called, so when I went to my room and saw that it wasn't handicapped they... more

We came to Monteagle for a family reunion and booked five rooms here. The check-in was manned by one person, so we had to wait a while to get checked in. However, this one person was always nice to whoever she was helping, no matter how difficult the person was. The hallways were usually very cold. The rooms had everything... more

Stayed 1-4 November 2007 for Homecoming Weekend at Sewanee. Easily the best motel in the area. The room was just like the one I recently used in a Holiday Inn Express - except there were no pictures in the room, the AC was quieter, and the room was newer, and the room card unlocked the door every time. Very comfortable... more

The only way we could make reservations was by calling directly. It was 90 dollars so expected high quality. We had a king executive suite...what a laugh....a room with a micro and fridge on a counter and calling it a wet bar. Only one bedstand, and was told that there was a dollar store down the road so I could... more

This was our second stay at this relatively new motel, and we'd hoped it had improved- it was, unfortunately, worse! The rooms are okay at best, and certainly don't warrant the $90 or so per night charged. The maid actually came into our room and did absolutely nothing but deliver towels. The beds were left unmade, and the coffeemaker was... more