You can safely ignore the negative review posted on September 21st 2007. This is a charming hotel with excellent food. more

The Western Isles of Scotland specialise - in our opinion - in terrible hotels. So to come across something like Highland Cottage is treasure indeed. But treasure doesn't come cheap. However, if you decided to book a stay there you will already know the rates. But believe me, this is truly one of life's gems as far as small hotels... more

My partner and I stayed here as part of a getaway to Mull. We were dealt with in a friendly matter from the moment of our first enquiry. The hotel itself is small but very well appointed, the room we stayed in, Staffa, was smallish but very very well looked after, the four posted bed was comfortable and luxurious, the... more

We booked this hotel largely because of the glowing reviews on here, but it wasn't as good as we had hoped. The hotel itself is lovely, as was our room; the food ranged from quite good to fantastic. Unfortunately - and the reason why we'll never go back - Dave, one of the owners, wasn't at all likeable. One of... more

I was searching for a hotel on the Isle of Mull and read all the reports on the various places. I settled on Tobermory and chose Highland Cottage. I am so pleased that we chose to stay there. In my estimation, this hotel is quite simply superb. The attention to detail is apparent, nothing is too much trouble and the... more

I knew nothing about accommodation on Mull when I started checking out websites but by a process of elimination and the information provided on their website I chose to contact the Highland Cottage Hotel to discuss staying for a few days in late September. From the time that I made the first call (when I was dealt with in a... more

I was disappointed in Highland Cottage, given the wonderful reputation and reviews I had read. I booked in for six nights and regretted it. Our room, supposedly the largest in the inn, was miniscule, overly-decorated, crowded with a useless couch, decorator pillows, books, and frilly lamps. The view of the water was over a foreground of rather dilapitated buildings. Our... more

We ate here two years ago on a local recommendation and were so impressed with the food and hospitality that on our return to Mull this year it was a must. Once again the whole evening was just superb. For the moment you are welcomed in to the moment you walk back out the door (many hours later) you are... more

We found Tobermory lovely although the harbourside was a bit less charming up close than tourism photos indicated; road works underway further diminished its slightly tired state. Highland Cottage is located on a quiet street well up the hill above a number (for a town of less than 800) of Main Street shops, however shopping wasn't our, nor should be... more