My single room with its thin partition walls looked as if it was furnished from the tatty leftovers from a jumble sale. Flakey paintwork was matched with manky carpets that were not particularly clean. The heating did not work and my request for an extra blanket was ignored as the room was not serviced - bed not made, loo rolls... more

this is the attached mail that I sent and got no response...they obviously are not interested Last week we stayed in your hotel whilst celebrating with our family at a function in the hall. We viewed the website and saw room two which suited our needs a double and single. I have to say the job done in promoting the... more

Room was quite simply awful - grubby walls, filthy, mould-ridden shower, hole in wall, bed uncomfortable, very cold. All in all - a very depressing place - like something out of a Dickens novel. The breakfast may be fine, but would not tempt me back in a thousand years. Don't be conned by the website pictures or descriptions - "warm... more

We came up for a two night stay for a wedding and were so deluded by the nice pictures on the Crieff Hotel's website and repelled by this place, I just had to join Trip Advisor to warn people off. Like JennaEdinburgh we were also 'squeezed in' for our second night as a result of double-booking - not sure what... more

I booked over the phone a month in advance. When we arrived, they had double booked but 'squeezed us in'. The bar and restaurant look nice but the rooms are ancient and need a complete overhaul. I would not walk barefoot on the bedroom carpets! A young child was banging on my ceiling from 5am and it would appear that... more

I'm not sure what others who wrote reviews about this place are use to, but by European standards this was more than acceptable for accomodations. Our room was spotless (and I do have a clean house). There was nothing filty dirty, nor were there any bugs? The food was great, the staff very friendly and downright funny. The pub entertainment... more

Came up for one night for a wedding. The staff were brilliant and arranged for us to have a room to use at 11:00am but the rooms themselves need pulling apart. My husband works as a maintenance manager of a hotel and could not believe the state that the rooms were in. Carpets stained and had cigarette burns. Wardrobes and... more

After reading the other reviews we thought it'd be fine. For other people to perceive the state the rooms are in as clean, I wouldn't like to know what their own houses are like. The staircases and the carpets hadn't been vacuumed I'd say for months. The curtains were literally brown with filth as it was everything else but the... more

Although the rooms are a little substandard in design, they are clean with all amenities. The key to this hotel is Martin the owner and the food. Go there expecting marginal rooms, great people and service. Be sure to check out M Brasserie - it was GREAT and very reasonably priced. more