I like the charm and character of old hotels, and this 84 year old hotel has both. Let me get this out of the way first. The hotel is not necessarily easy to find by car due to the one way streets; and getting to the parking structure entrance is worse. The neighborhood is a mix of nice buildings and... more

We stayed here for one night in September. The hotel is very beautiful although I can't say the same for the location. Because they are a pet friendly hotel we brought our cocker spaniel but we weren't comfortable taking her for a walk late in the evening. We didn't encounter any problems but the area just didn't appear safe to... more

My spouse and I have stayed in this hotel a few times in the past. We have found the beds extremely comfortable. The staff has always been very professional and accomodating. On out last visit, the staff exceeded anything I would expect. We suddenly had a need to extend our stay, and all was booked for the addtional time. The... more

All staff that we encountered were very friendly. They were quite refreshing to deal with compared to the crabby or cold service I find in many hotels these days! the lobby area, reastaurant/main floor is beautiful. The upstairs hallways need new carpet as it is old and stained. The rooms are huge and clean. The hotel is very clean throughout... more

Great historical hotel. Entire staff is welcoming and very accommodating. My rooms are always very large and clean. An absolute pleasure to stay there! more

The valet staff damaged my car and would take no responsibility for it. The valet drivers back the cars in to a yellow fence in their garage, and when I got my car back, the car had yellow scratches on the back bumper. It was difficult to get the hotel manager to call me back, and when he did, he... more

We booked our stay at the Yorktowne through Genesis Golf Trips. We were looking for a combination of golf, shopping and sightseeing. The Yorktowne is a lovely, old hotel centrally located for trips to Hershey, Lancaster and Gettysburg. The rooms are large and nicely decorated. There is a casual grill for all meals and a four star dinner restaurant that... more

Stayed there for a wedding, everything was fine initially. this is a historic building, lobby was great. room was different story. old and tired. rug wasn't very inviting. bed was great. wallpaper been up too long, just a lot of wear and tear. woke up sunday morning because wife is yelling for me to come into the bathroom, big cockroaches... more

We have stayed twice now at this hotel. It is a beautiful old building right in downtown York. The rooms are clean, spacious and well-kept. They have nice amenities but don't expect luxury - they are nice rooms. The front desk is very professional and helpful - they will give you a map of the local area! You are in... more