My wife and I wanted to experience the atmosphere of Put-in-Bay. After reading several negative reviews, I was pleasantly surprised to find a friendly staff and a clean, spacious, well-maintained room. In fact, it appeared that our unit had been refurbished quite recently. Our experience got off to a great start when we hooked up with one of the hotel... more

Just got back from Put in Bay, Ohio. This was my 1st trip there. I am a travel agent with 24 years experience. I have stayed in some very posh hotels and have also stayed in some dumps. I was pleasantly surprised with the Edgewater. The rooms were clean and very spacious. The 1st night we were there we stayed... more

I realize that when calling to make reservations, the customer service representative we spoke with takes reservations for more than one hotel and may have inadvertently given us the wrong information, but this is the experience we had. When making reservations for our first stay at Put-In-Bay, we asked many questions concerning accommodations. The customer service representative was very helpful... more

When the "sheeple" get off the ferry with their wallets Edgewater and company are ready. The room we got was not what they said we were going to get. Our golf cart was constantly passed by other golf carts because of what seemed like a fuel line problem. The complaint about that was completely ignored. Mr. Ed's bar next door... more

I decided to organize a trip to Put in Bay,Ohio. We had three fathers, my husband terminally ill,our young son, and my brother who just lost a son to a tragic train accident at 18 years old. I was hoping for a breath of fresh air,to relax and unwind just a little.The rooms that i reserved and confirmed three times... more

The room was relatively clean, and large. The beds are probably from 1950, with a dip in the middle so big it's like laying in a hammock. We are not partiers, which is all the island is for, so we planned on going to bed at 11pm. Not happening. Heavy metal band at the bar next door, 30 feet away,... more

This place was gross. In summary, picture what would happen if you opened a new hotel, then unleashed spring breakers on it for a year or two. Nasty carpets, spartan furniture, HORRIBLE smoky smell. The check-in process was complicated. We had to walk down a dark street in an unfamilar area to find the other hotel at which we checked... more

i booked my hotel room back in may for my june stay i did the 125$ a nite for the suite with a free golf cart for the entire stay considering most folks on the isle rent golf carts for 60$ a day it was worth it the room was on the 2nd floorand it had a kitchenette microwave and... more

After I booked the room, I started to read the reviews from this site and got a little worried. So I contacted the hotel and asked them about the reviews and was told that most of them were written by their competition and that they were remodeled in 2006. I felt a little better, until I checked in!!!! The bad... more