This was a great place to stay with our dog! Very basic but clean accomodations. Extremely close to the beach. Property manager was easy going, but helpful and responsive -- broken toilet was fixed immediately after we mentioned it.

Nice location on the Old Montauk Highway and a short drive to town. Beach is across the road and down some steps. The owner Ron is a nice guy and very helpful. My main comment is that the cottages are quite dowdy with old sagging sofas, rickety tables and gaudy patterns galore. Considering these cottages are $250+ a night in... More

Our trip to Lenhart's Cottages had to be postponed twice due to bad weather and illness but our third try was a charm. We stayed in cottage number two for two nights and the cottage and trip was exactly what my wife and two dogs were looking for. Although the temperatures were below average for this time of year, the... More

I met some friends for Presidents day weekend and it was a great stay! The cabin was two bedrooms and a sleeper sofa so there was plenty of room for everyone. The wood burning fireplace, free wifi, energy efficient washer and dryer and a full kitchen made our 6 night stay very comfortable. Each night we cooked dinner and watched... More

My partner and I just returned from a New Year's stay at Lenhart's in Montauk and had a great time. If you're looking for a quiet, romantic getaway in a cottage with a fireplace AND a view of the ocean--and not looking for the latest in bath products and spa services---then I recommend this place highly. And the owner, Ron,... More

We visited in mid September, and we LOVED Lenhart's. The LOCATION is PERFECT—big windows onto views of the ocean from your living room and kitchen. A lovely private (?) and mostly empty beach is just across the old highway from Lenhart's. Our dog had the time of her life running around on the beach. Our lovely, spacious cottage had everything... More

My husband & I wanted to get away for a bit of rest & relaxation, before we enter into our busy [business] season. I had been coming out to Montauk for years & staying @ a place just east of Lenhart's. This year I got married & we got a dog & wanted a "pet" friendly place to stay. The... More

NO Wi-Fi to distract from the sound of the ocean waves, the night sky filled with stars, fresh air, clean rooms, a refreshing pool overlooking the Atlantic, and a perfect cottage getaway to escape from our hectic lives! Thank you, Ron, for keeping this oasis going for so many years! We just spent our 26th anniversary in Montauk, and happily... More

I have been staying with my family at Lenhart's Cottages in Montauk for the past 12 years. The location is perfect, across from a quiet stretch of the beach, and the full service cottages provide a home away from home. The caretaker is friendly and "laid back" and always makes superb recommendations for dinner and entertainment. It is a child... More